Book of Heroes

Mercenaries

I think that there should be a 48 hrs penalty on people leaving a guild. I have seen people joining a guild just to do a raid and then leaving it. I know that many would disagree with me but as a guild master I feel that guild should stick together thought thick and thin no matter what.
I totally understand what you are saying but on the flip side, some of these mercenaries have really helped my guild with harder raids. I tend to like incentives vs. punishments. Some have suggested having a guild armory that one can only draw upon while in the guild - leaving will cause you to lose the items. I like this idea. But as someone who loves her guild & wants to encourage loyalty, I see your point.
I would agree with that 48h penalty, because the guilds and the guilds quests and raids are meant to be a way to challenge your guildies and teammates and create a strong and friendly spirit between them.

The actual system doesnt offer that as a mercenary is only interested in the rewards (tokens and valors) and this is not the spirit that should be present in a guild.
I guess the easy penalty is to never accept these Mercenaries into your Guild again. Eventually they'll run out of Guilds.
Pfaff wrote:I guess the easy penalty is to never accept these Mercenaries into your Guild again. Eventually they'll run out of Guilds.
That's never going to happen. There are more than 1.7k guilds out there and only about 50 are near full strength. So there will always be space for mercs.
I disagree with the OP completely. I and others in my primary guild do leave to do merc work. The owner is fine with it.

As far as the guilds that I do merc work for, I only join those begging for raid help on global chat. It is a win-win situation.

You can run your guild however you want but everybody should get to run it the way they want as well. The current system is fine.

Swashbuckling_DrarrrrrrgonChick

ModeratorMon Jul 2, 2012 6:46 pm
I agree with Bbbb. I am totally committed to my guild, am active on guild chat, and raid with them every day. However, I also take my alt character out of the guild to raid with other guilds when they ask for help on global chat. I enjoy meeting other people that way as well as fitting in more raiding. Most of my guild are asleep in my morning, so being a Merc is an effective use of my time when my guild isn't raiding.

If you don't want mercs to help in your raids, don't ask for help in global chat. Likewise, if you don't want your members to roam, make that clear as a leader. I asked and received my guild masters permission before I tried it. It's about loyalty, respect, helping out others, and above all having fun! It is a game after all...
Then what's the point in having guilds to carry out raids. Venan should remove the concept of guilds. There is no use of guilds other than to carry out raids. If you want to carry out raid, you just go to global chat and ask for people willing to carry out the raid. Form a group of 20-25 people and start raiding. Also the power and prestige of the guilds that use mercs is not their own. Mercs help them get along and complete the raid but in the end it doesn't help them as they will keep on depending on others to come and help them instead of relying on their selves. One of the reasons that there are so many guilds with so few members.
When I first started playing I was a guild hopper. I just couldn't find a guild that raided enough or at the right times. If your guild is raiding all the time, your people will have no need to go merc. Focus on building a solid group of officers in multiple time zones and try to always have a raid going. If they want raids, give em raids!!!
The other purpose of a guild is a chat room among friends. Not just purely raiding.

Many guilds are using mercs till they can fill up their ranks and then they quit using them.