A guild lacks of hardcore or GS players will grow stronger, a guild lacks of dedicated players will not survive. Definition of "dedicated" is be able to pop in pop out daily. This game does not require you to go hardcore like play none stop for 4+ hours straight. Pop in pop out system works great so that players can do their real life stuff while enjoying jump in the game here and there during the day. Full energy burn takes only 5~15 minutes. Guilds that have many dedicated players will grow stronger and stronger because their raids will most likely be successful. Guilds that don't have such players, even if all 60 are on, raids may still fail if half or more of that 60 never come back.
Mercenaries · page 3
I honestly have no problem with mercs. I'm a GM also, but the way I see it, it benefits both parties. The mercs get their valor, and the guild gets their raid completion. Besides, I don't think people should get penalized for playing the way they want to...
When the Guild Might Threshold is added to the system, I think we'll see more mercing, especially from high might toons.
Here's how it could work: each guild sets their Might threshold to the lowest Might they will accept. No more 120 might level 4 newbies applying to the top Guilds where they would be best employed as footstools. The Guilds can then happily use auto-accept to receive mercenaries that could fight alongside their regulars without getting their ranks swamped by wet-behind-the-ears just-out-of-training-diapers hopefuls who can't be bothered to read the guild requirements.
The very topmost exclusive Guilds might keep auto-accept off and require an applicate to pass an interview, but most Guilds even in the top ten would be happy to have a little help to finish raids to ease the burden on their regulars. Nobody benefits from a failed raid.
The Guild I'm in has a quiet period between noon and 6pm EDT due to most members being at work or asleep, depending on their planetary location. When farming during this period becomes almost pointless (the rewards being so paltry compared to the effort expended) I'd happily go join a high level raid (Cursed Keep or above) for another Guild, just to earn the KV I need to keep improving my Gems.
My own Guild would benefit too, because my character would be ready for the War of Fellmarsh that much sooner. It's a win-win situation, as long as I return for our regular raids with a full energy bar.
Here's how it could work: each guild sets their Might threshold to the lowest Might they will accept. No more 120 might level 4 newbies applying to the top Guilds where they would be best employed as footstools. The Guilds can then happily use auto-accept to receive mercenaries that could fight alongside their regulars without getting their ranks swamped by wet-behind-the-ears just-out-of-training-diapers hopefuls who can't be bothered to read the guild requirements.
The very topmost exclusive Guilds might keep auto-accept off and require an applicate to pass an interview, but most Guilds even in the top ten would be happy to have a little help to finish raids to ease the burden on their regulars. Nobody benefits from a failed raid.
The Guild I'm in has a quiet period between noon and 6pm EDT due to most members being at work or asleep, depending on their planetary location. When farming during this period becomes almost pointless (the rewards being so paltry compared to the effort expended) I'd happily go join a high level raid (Cursed Keep or above) for another Guild, just to earn the KV I need to keep improving my Gems.
My own Guild would benefit too, because my character would be ready for the War of Fellmarsh that much sooner. It's a win-win situation, as long as I return for our regular raids with a full energy bar.
Two months since my last post on this topic, and Mercenaries are bouncing round the top 20 or so Guilds like pinballs.
The lower Guilds also regularly advertise for help from Mercenaries, and if there are no KV raids asking for help we sometimes bounce down and help them out too. Some Guilds are forming alliances, advertising each other's raids, and even rate Mercenaries as allied or rogue, with restrictions on the RPP to which Mercenaries are expected to restrict themselves.
Obviously we need Guilds or there'd be no raids for the Mercenaries to attend, but with high burnout/dropout rates in the higher guilds, partly due to lack of new (or interesting & challenging) content for the top toons, partly due to people just playing the game too much, Mercenaries have become the oil that keeps the gears turning for many guilds.
The intelligent use of the Might Threshold combined with auto-accept has made mercing far easier. Some Guilds advertise for mercenaries but keep their doors locked. If a merc waits too long and sees another advert in Global, they'll usually move on.
Some Guilds have labelled themselves as Mercenary haters and that's fine, just don't ask for Mercenary help, and keep your doors locked to avoid unwanted intrusion, and we'll leave you alone.
Meantime those of us who act as Mercenaries get the opportunity to sample the chat and atmosphere in many different Guilds, and make new friends and allies, and often the satisfaction of helping a raid complete that was previously in trouble.
I feel much more a part of a Global community as a Mercenary than I did when I restricted my playing time to a single Guild, and I don't really care about the Power/Prestige tables at all. Power is really only a reflection of the last 3-4 days raids, and Prestige jumps up and down as high power toons switch Guilds.
The lower Guilds also regularly advertise for help from Mercenaries, and if there are no KV raids asking for help we sometimes bounce down and help them out too. Some Guilds are forming alliances, advertising each other's raids, and even rate Mercenaries as allied or rogue, with restrictions on the RPP to which Mercenaries are expected to restrict themselves.
Obviously we need Guilds or there'd be no raids for the Mercenaries to attend, but with high burnout/dropout rates in the higher guilds, partly due to lack of new (or interesting & challenging) content for the top toons, partly due to people just playing the game too much, Mercenaries have become the oil that keeps the gears turning for many guilds.
The intelligent use of the Might Threshold combined with auto-accept has made mercing far easier. Some Guilds advertise for mercenaries but keep their doors locked. If a merc waits too long and sees another advert in Global, they'll usually move on.
Some Guilds have labelled themselves as Mercenary haters and that's fine, just don't ask for Mercenary help, and keep your doors locked to avoid unwanted intrusion, and we'll leave you alone.
Meantime those of us who act as Mercenaries get the opportunity to sample the chat and atmosphere in many different Guilds, and make new friends and allies, and often the satisfaction of helping a raid complete that was previously in trouble.
I feel much more a part of a Global community as a Mercenary than I did when I restricted my playing time to a single Guild, and I don't really care about the Power/Prestige tables at all. Power is really only a reflection of the last 3-4 days raids, and Prestige jumps up and down as high power toons switch Guilds.
I recently did some merc work with one of my alts to get him to the might level of our guild's highest raid. I also enjoyed experiencing the different environments. Similarly, the guild rankings for power mean very little when a lot of mercs are working for a guild. I agree that no merc or guild should be penalized for this, but perhaps a different formula for power could be used... for example, the power contributed by a char's RPP in a raid could be removed when the char leaves, thus if half of your raid was carried by mercs, your guild only keeps half the power.
Pfaff, your 29 Sept post truly sums it all up... thanks