I think riposte is just the perfect example of what happens when you let too much rely on rng. You can completely destroy your opponent if you get your ripostes to work in your favor however you can also riposte yourself into oblivion if it triggers at all the wrong times or not have an effect at all if it never triggers at all.
The problem is that you are no more skilled for taking the ability than you were before making the decision to use it. It is out of your hands other than requiring you to be smart and gem for dodge if you decide to use it (If you dont then this thread isnt for you).
Id like to expound on my dodge idea a little bit to illustrate how I would implement dodge. So your dodge rating is real low and you want to dodge an attack...your dodge button gives you a .02s dodge timer that you have to nail like block in order to dodge. Its on a .5s refresh timer too. In another case, you are an endgame pvp shadowwalker who gems out the wazoo for dodge, your dodge window may be .16s with a .35s refresh. If you want to dodge half the time, then you need to sacrifice some offense for taking 0 damage.
Also, I definitely agree that activated abilities like juggernaut help separate the skilled from the unskilled. More abilities need to be like this, player activated an completely uncoupled from flat % chances to work.
Put more control into the players hands and pvp will be much more enjoyable.
p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.
The problem is that you are no more skilled for taking the ability than you were before making the decision to use it. It is out of your hands other than requiring you to be smart and gem for dodge if you decide to use it (If you dont then this thread isnt for you).
Id like to expound on my dodge idea a little bit to illustrate how I would implement dodge. So your dodge rating is real low and you want to dodge an attack...your dodge button gives you a .02s dodge timer that you have to nail like block in order to dodge. Its on a .5s refresh timer too. In another case, you are an endgame pvp shadowwalker who gems out the wazoo for dodge, your dodge window may be .16s with a .35s refresh. If you want to dodge half the time, then you need to sacrifice some offense for taking 0 damage.
Also, I definitely agree that activated abilities like juggernaut help separate the skilled from the unskilled. More abilities need to be like this, player activated an completely uncoupled from flat % chances to work.
Put more control into the players hands and pvp will be much more enjoyable.
p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.