Book of Heroes

Critical Hits in PvP's First Season · page 2

I think riposte is just the perfect example of what happens when you let too much rely on rng. You can completely destroy your opponent if you get your ripostes to work in your favor however you can also riposte yourself into oblivion if it triggers at all the wrong times or not have an effect at all if it never triggers at all.

The problem is that you are no more skilled for taking the ability than you were before making the decision to use it. It is out of your hands other than requiring you to be smart and gem for dodge if you decide to use it (If you dont then this thread isnt for you).

Id like to expound on my dodge idea a little bit to illustrate how I would implement dodge. So your dodge rating is real low and you want to dodge an attack...your dodge button gives you a .02s dodge timer that you have to nail like block in order to dodge. Its on a .5s refresh timer too. In another case, you are an endgame pvp shadowwalker who gems out the wazoo for dodge, your dodge window may be .16s with a .35s refresh. If you want to dodge half the time, then you need to sacrifice some offense for taking 0 damage.

Also, I definitely agree that activated abilities like juggernaut help separate the skilled from the unskilled. More abilities need to be like this, player activated an completely uncoupled from flat % chances to work.

Put more control into the players hands and pvp will be much more enjoyable.

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.
Gster wrote:I think riposte is just the perfect example of what happens when you let too much rely on rng. You can completely destroy your opponent if you get your ripostes to work in your favor however you can also riposte yourself into oblivion if it triggers at all the wrong times or not have an effect at all if it never triggers at all.

The problem is that you are no more skilled for taking the ability than you were before making the decision to use it. It is out of your hands other than requiring you to be smart and gem for dodge if you decide to use it (If you dont then this thread isnt for you).

Id like to expound on my dodge idea a little bit to illustrate how I would implement dodge. So your dodge rating is real low and you want to dodge an attack...your dodge button gives you a .02s dodge timer that you have to nail like block in order to dodge. Its on a .5s refresh timer too. In another case, you are an endgame pvp shadowwalker who gems out the wazoo for dodge, your dodge window may be .16s with a .35s refresh. If you want to dodge half the time, then you need to sacrifice some offense for taking 0 damage.

Also, I definitely agree that activated abilities like juggernaut help separate the skilled from the unskilled. More abilities need to be like this, player activated an completely uncoupled from flat % chances to work.

Put more control into the players hands and pvp will be much more enjoyable.

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.

With the way Dodge currently benefits - against any WM attack, and many poison/spirit attacks - you still take 50% damage and have to resist status as well, plus some skills (Caltrops, Net, Grenade, Smoke) can't be dodged at all. Considering this, a more 'active' Dodge option simply wouldn't be worth it. I've dodged Incinerate to still take 6k damage and be set on fire, for example. If a dodge made damage 0 and no status effect, then an active Dodge option would be kinda cool.

Quite honestly, the entire defensive option mechanic could do with revision. Having multiple options for Block (only available to shield-equipped toons) / Dodge (as it sounds) / Steadfast (similar to current, offering an all-round defensive bonus, but less of a Dodge bonus than Dodge, less of a Block bonus than Block). I also think the cd should be removed on defence - if someone just wants to defend and wait for their opening, why not? That's what happens for realz. You hope you can weather the punishment long enough to get your own big hit. It's a dangerous tactic because you're handing initiative to your opponent, but opens up a whole new strategy.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Sep 23, 2014 4:45 am
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Gster wrote:I think riposte is just the perfect example of what happens when you let too much rely on rng. You can completely destroy your opponent if you get your ripostes to work in your favor however you can also riposte yourself into oblivion if it triggers at all the wrong times or not have an effect at all if it never triggers at all.

The problem is that you are no more skilled for taking the ability than you were before making the decision to use it. It is out of your hands other than requiring you to be smart and gem for dodge if you decide to use it (If you dont then this thread isnt for you).

Id like to expound on my dodge idea a little bit to illustrate how I would implement dodge. So your dodge rating is real low and you want to dodge an attack...your dodge button gives you a .02s dodge timer that you have to nail like block in order to dodge. Its on a .5s refresh timer too. In another case, you are an endgame pvp shadowwalker who gems out the wazoo for dodge, your dodge window may be .16s with a .35s refresh. If you want to dodge half the time, then you need to sacrifice some offense for taking 0 damage.

Also, I definitely agree that activated abilities like juggernaut help separate the skilled from the unskilled. More abilities need to be like this, player activated an completely uncoupled from flat % chances to work.

Put more control into the players hands and pvp will be much more enjoyable.

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.

With the way Dodge currently benefits - against any WM attack, and many poison/spirit attacks - you still take 50% damage and have to resist status as well, plus some skills (Caltrops, Net, Grenade, Smoke) can't be dodged at all. Considering this, a more 'active' Dodge option simply wouldn't be worth it. I've dodged Incinerate to still take 6k damage and be set on fire, for example. If a dodge made damage 0 and no status effect, then an active Dodge option would be kinda cool.

Quite honestly, the entire defensive option mechanic could do with revision. Having multiple options for Block (only available to shield-equipped toons) / Dodge (as it sounds) / Steadfast (similar to current, offering an all-round defensive bonus, but less of a Dodge bonus than Dodge, less of a Block bonus than Block). I also think the cd should be removed on defence - if someone just wants to defend and wait for their opening, why not? That's what happens for realz. You hope you can weather the punishment long enough to get your own big hit. It's a dangerous tactic because you're handing initiative to your opponent, but opens up a whole new strategy.

Agree. The 'dodge' you get vs spells is hardly a dodge at all. You can still take massive damage and status. Maybe a 'dodged' spell should also avoid any status effect. Otherwise you haven't really dodged, have you? You've just taken half damage.
Exactly. The entire dodge mechanic is highly biased against physical attacks. I really dont understand the extreme difference in the way dodge deals with the two different attack types, and the random mechanics in place to make up for the difference (backswing, riposte) are consolation prizes to the actual debuff or knockback that you wanted to land.
Gster wrote:Exactly. The entire dodge mechanic is highly biased against physical attacks. I really dont understand the extreme difference in the way dodge deals with the two different attack types, and the random mechanics in place to make up for the difference (backswing, riposte) are consolation prizes to the actual debuff or knockback that you wanted to land.

Just a little BOH history lesson, back 2 years ago, there was no magic dodge at all. You were hit full strength every time. Of course, it didn't matter much as mages were terrible back then.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Sep 23, 2014 7:18 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Gster wrote:Exactly. The entire dodge mechanic is highly biased against physical attacks. I really dont understand the extreme difference in the way dodge deals with the two different attack types, and the random mechanics in place to make up for the difference (backswing, riposte) are consolation prizes to the actual debuff or knockback that you wanted to land.

Just a little BOH history lesson, back 2 years ago, there was no magic dodge at all. You were hit full strength every time. Of course, it didn't matter much as mages were terrible back then.

You mean back when PvP didn't exist?

japster

ModeratorThu Sep 25, 2014 10:08 am
Gster wrote:

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.

Then allow it to be at a 100% chance to hit at least if that was the case. Because while snap cast spells now can crit, they may also be dodged/blocked. So if you want to remove the extremely positive roll outcomes, at least remove the negative roll outcomes too to balance it out.
japster wrote:
Gster wrote:

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.

Then allow it to be at a 100% chance to hit at least if that was the case. Because while snap cast spells now can crit, they may also be dodged/blocked. So if you want to remove the extremely positive roll outcomes, at least remove the negative roll outcomes too to balance it out.

You dont think that removing the ability cast time, regardless of buff/debuff status is useful enough by itself?

japster

ModeratorSat Sep 27, 2014 4:19 am
Gster wrote:
japster wrote:
Gster wrote:

p.s. in my opinion snap cast would be perfectly balanced if skills casted with the ability couldnt crit.

Then allow it to be at a 100% chance to hit at least if that was the case. Because while snap cast spells now can crit, they may also be dodged/blocked. So if you want to remove the extremely positive roll outcomes, at least remove the negative roll outcomes too to balance it out.

You dont think that removing the ability cast time, regardless of buff/debuff status is useful enough by itself?

Not if it gets dodged or blocked or resisted.

I was already being very fair to request that it only be unblockable and undodgeable IF it was gonna be unable to crit. Note I didn't ask for it to be unresistable as well ;) Logic is simple. If you want to remove the chance for a damage spike, I think it's only fair that it shouldn't be dodged or blocked. That way everyone knows the damage of the spell will be consistent. It won't crit and turn the fight around, but neither will it be reduced rendering it ineffective. Do note that spells still roll for their resist modifiers whether it is blocked or dodged, so I didn't ask for that component to be made unresistable even if crit was removed. Fair =)

With your argument, we might as well say that all skills should be nerfed one way or the other because they all have a useful aspect. And going further, should we therefore impose a new rule that all skills that have been "instant cast" be unable to crit? So Riposte and Backswing attacks can no longer crit? I don't see why Snapcast should be singled out to be unable to roll for crits when mages only get a chance to use it ONCE a fight (generally) whereas the other classes potentially can use their "instant" attacks more than once and still have it crit.

If it's not broken, don't fix it.

P.S. Backswing probably not an on-point example, but Riposte definitely is.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Sep 27, 2014 6:42 am
Well, with Riposte the ability queued can still be dodged/defended so I see nothing wrong with that ability. I don't there's anything wrong with snap cast any more per se since the latest balances. Backswing still has issues about the amount of damage it does (a number of players have worked out that the way damage is worked out for it isn't correct compared to other Justicar abilities - I'll let them elaborate if they want to).