Book of Heroes

Critical Hits in PvP's First Season

So what are peoples thoughts on crits?

IMO they make to much of a swing factor. Yes PvP is luck based but it galls me when I receive an 11K+ hit that takes me from pretty much half HP to dead before I can make that one last hit I need to make myself. And I feel bad for the other guy when I'm the one landing the crit.

So I'm wondering if we could somehow tweak crits in PvP like HP has been tweaked. I'm not sure if it should be damage or chance or both but I'm frustrated by crits in general and would like to see some experimentation.

Agree? Disagree?

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Sep 21, 2014 3:45 pm
I think your point in reducing crit would be to remove some of the luck factor, however, in so doing you would be removing a minor component of the luck factor; considering there are so many other luck factors (status resists, bleed/burning procs, riposte, dodges, blocks, arcane shield procs, etc etc) I do not believe it would be beneficial.

Unless you can remove all luck factor and make PvP more of a pure strategy/game of chess style battle, we might as well enjoy the wild Crit variations along with all the other variables that make PvP battles such a crap shoot (considering relatively equivalent gear/builds..which frankly, all top toons have essentially the exact same builds).

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Sep 21, 2014 5:25 pm
Mithrid wrote:I think your point in reducing crit would be to remove some of the luck factor, however, in so doing you would be removing a minor component of the luck factor; considering there are so many other luck factors (status resists, bleed/burning procs, riposte, dodges, blocks, arcane shield procs, etc etc) I do not believe it would be beneficial.

Unless you can remove all luck factor and make PvP more of a pure strategy/game of chess style battle, we might as well enjoy the wild Crit variations along with all the other variables that make PvP battles such a crap shoot (considering relatively equivalent gear/builds..which frankly, all top toons have essentially the exact same builds).


Have to agree, I wish PvP was more about strategy and skill but it really isn't. It's about who resists and dodges most. If you resist a lot in a match or dodge loads, you'll probably win. It's just praying to the random number god, not the skill-based system that was first mentioned back when it was still beta.
All or nothing resists and dodges are the largest problem in my opinion.

A dodge should be a button press with a cooldown, and all hard resists should be the result of using a short duration ability (ala juggernaut). Otherwise, with characters having over 30% resists and 50% dodge we might as well replace character graphics with animations of coin flips and dice rolls and call it a day.
There is a skill element. Or at least a choice element in pvp. You know your opponent has used x ability and that allows you to use y ability because of cool downs heroic will excluded which excludes an entire class but I digress.

I agree, too much coin flipping and rng...
Ok i have done probally 5k fights total on 5 toons and yes crits are some luck but also i win matches by a lucky resist or dodge i also lose matches like this. I mean having a 20k smite with 3 lvl 7 defense migrations with only one spirit stack on is sometjing that needs work imo. Then the arcane shield bugs for wm like it is taken away with attacks like time void, smoke bomb, or even an ice shield. Then the fact that wm get screwed over if they have an arcan shield and want to defend sticky its like 2 negatives mage a positive they cancel each other out which sucks. Then a lot of justis complain that their sesmic slash has a less hit rate than other attacks i believe that this is true honestly i havent seen any test but just playing my justi it feels like it hits less. Then the snap 10k crit with a wm needs to be taken into account that really sucks and it impossible to deal with. Then the case with the new t17 weapon that 1h sw and 1h justis get to use it is a bit infair they get the weapon and a 19% bonus which i dont believe is fair. Then the sticky bomb double stack is a lie if you "stack" the second one it still is a 2 second timer it just takes half of the dot only reason i do it is to throw people timers off.

Op attacks
1.Jugg
2.nuero stab
3. Heroic will
4. Garrote
5. Snap cast

These are my top 5 most op attacks jugg for obvious purposes. Nuero stab because if ised correctly can really screw people over. Heroic will is op if used correctly i mean throwing off regen times is awesome
Garrote killing dodge is huge in pvp as some people rely soely on dodge. Snap cast as if that attack crits its a huge hit... Nothing you can do

_Salad

These were just some of my thoughts of pvp now

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Sep 22, 2014 12:45 am
King_Fizz wrote:

These are my top 5 most op attacks jugg for obvious purposes. Nuero stab because if ised correctly can really screw people over. Heroic will is op if used correctly i mean throwing off regen times is awesome
Garrote killing dodge is huge in pvp as some people rely soely on dodge. Snap cast as if that attack crits its a huge hit... Nothing you can do

_Salad

These were just some of my thoughts of pvp now

Salad, while I like some of your thoughts, I think for the purposes of this thread you should separate concerns about certain attacks and defense buffs being OP when their use is purely strategic, from those PvP aspects that are just lucky based.

Example, all your op concerns about jugg and snapcast, I feel those two attacks in particular are very strategic, Knowing when best to use them and how they can affect your opponent is pure strategy. And because jugg is 100% and snapcasts use is 100%, the luck factor in that regard is a non issue, their use is perfectly strategic. (now launching a snapcast only to have your opponent dodge and then riposte...well... welcome to the luck factor).

Some of your other points however, such as seismic not hitting as often as other attacks (I've noticed this as well both as a defender as well as an attacker) play into the luck factor as a dominant PvP attribute.

I think in this discussion it is important to recognize the difference.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 22, 2014 3:45 am
I think the seismic 'problems' are heavy observation bias. It's the only kb that can be completely dodged, so I'm not too surprised we're seeing players complain about it.

Not going to talk about bugs like Mith said. This was about the luck factor and the fact that all we're doing half the time is coin flipping. Most of the 'bugs' people complain about are not actually bugs, just things they want nerfed.
Maybe I should of titled this RNG in PvP's... It certainly is getting discussed enough. :p

Yes there is an element of skill. Choice and cool downs and all as mentioned. And some abilities are purely strategic. But that's why I want to try and tweak things so skill is more of a factor than luck. Was thinking I might try and address other issues later seperatly. If it's all discussed in this thread that's fine too.

And completly of topic I think I'd replace NS with Riposte for an OP ability. And I'd almost feel bad for the WMs only having one on the top 5 but seeing as how often they beat me I can't say I sympathise.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 22, 2014 2:40 pm
Phunbaba wrote:Maybe I should of titled this RNG in PvP's... It certainly is getting discussed enough. :p

Yes there is an element of skill. Choice and cool downs and all as mentioned. And some abilities are purely strategic. But that's why I want to try and tweak things so skill is more of a factor than luck. Was thinking I might try and address other issues later seperatly. If it's all discussed in this thread that's fine too.

And completly of topic I think I'd replace NS with Riposte for an OP ability. And I'd almost feel bad for the WMs only having one on the top 5 but seeing as how often they beat me I can't say I sympathise.

Top 5 changes almost daily mate. Also of late a WM has been #1, so I don't feel bad for WMs at all. They can still do crits at ~20k might that SW won't see until 35 if they're lucky.

It's been discussed and explained elsewhere, Riposte is not an OP skill. If Riposte is OP then half the abilities of all 3 classes are too.