I havent exactly put forth an argument, yet, in favour of my opinion regarding snapcast. I have just stated that it is my opinion that it would be balanced without the ability to crit.
If you were snapcasting physical attacks I could see your argument, as status effects would have zero chance to land if the ability was dodged. But with spells, even if they are dodged, like you say, they still have the ability to cause status effects.
The only thing you lose is huge damage spikes. And really, the fact that you even entered into this argument shows that, at least on some level, you know that snapcast, even in its current revision, is still a little over the top.
Honestly though, if your argument didnt mean a 100% chance KB with ice lance I wouldnt have as much of a problem with it. But I dont think it would be to anyones advantage to start mixing and matching what snap cast does with each individual spell. A fix aimed at a universal mechanic would probably help more than nerfing a single ability, I do agree.
In addition, I would also question backswing being labeled an instant cast ability. It cannot trigger until the full ability timer of a physical attack has timed down and that ability is dodged completely. Its more of a consolation prize than anything, removing any chance that a knockback or a status will be imparted to your opponent with the attack.
If you were snapcasting physical attacks I could see your argument, as status effects would have zero chance to land if the ability was dodged. But with spells, even if they are dodged, like you say, they still have the ability to cause status effects.
The only thing you lose is huge damage spikes. And really, the fact that you even entered into this argument shows that, at least on some level, you know that snapcast, even in its current revision, is still a little over the top.
Honestly though, if your argument didnt mean a 100% chance KB with ice lance I wouldnt have as much of a problem with it. But I dont think it would be to anyones advantage to start mixing and matching what snap cast does with each individual spell. A fix aimed at a universal mechanic would probably help more than nerfing a single ability, I do agree.
In addition, I would also question backswing being labeled an instant cast ability. It cannot trigger until the full ability timer of a physical attack has timed down and that ability is dodged completely. Its more of a consolation prize than anything, removing any chance that a knockback or a status will be imparted to your opponent with the attack.