Book of Heroes

Critical Hits in PvP's First Season · page 3

I havent exactly put forth an argument, yet, in favour of my opinion regarding snapcast. I have just stated that it is my opinion that it would be balanced without the ability to crit.

If you were snapcasting physical attacks I could see your argument, as status effects would have zero chance to land if the ability was dodged. But with spells, even if they are dodged, like you say, they still have the ability to cause status effects.
The only thing you lose is huge damage spikes. And really, the fact that you even entered into this argument shows that, at least on some level, you know that snapcast, even in its current revision, is still a little over the top.

Honestly though, if your argument didnt mean a 100% chance KB with ice lance I wouldnt have as much of a problem with it. But I dont think it would be to anyones advantage to start mixing and matching what snap cast does with each individual spell. A fix aimed at a universal mechanic would probably help more than nerfing a single ability, I do agree.

In addition, I would also question backswing being labeled an instant cast ability. It cannot trigger until the full ability timer of a physical attack has timed down and that ability is dodged completely. Its more of a consolation prize than anything, removing any chance that a knockback or a status will be imparted to your opponent with the attack.

japster

ModeratorSun Sep 28, 2014 6:08 am
Gster wrote:
The only thing you lose is huge damage spikes. And really, the fact that you even entered into this argument shows that, at least on some level, you know that snapcast, even in its current revision, is still a little over the top.

Please don't assume you know why I entered into this discussion. I only entered the debate because it was my opinion that you suggested a terrible nerf to snapcast for no good reason. For the record, I don't think snapcast is OP any longer after the various revisions to its cooldown and warmup periods. ONCE a fight in almost any match. It doesn't need anymore nerfing. If any aspect of it is to be nerfed, then it has to be counterbalanced in another way.

We can put aside backswing since I already said it wasn't an on-point comparison.

The fact that you noticed my suggestion would lead to a 100% kb ice lance shows that you are cognizant why snapcast + ice lance combo now isn't as powerful as it potentially could be on paper, because there's a decent chance for it to be dodged/blocked right now. And therein lies the whole point. The crit aspect of snapcast can be easily negated by dodge and block rates. So the damage of snapcast is balanced.

Crit and dodge rates are equal on stat progression, i.e. 100 points in dodge leads to the same % increase in its corresponding stat as 100 points in crit would. Moreover, other classes can improve their dodge and block rate way higher than gem stats (through abilities such as Quickness, Elder Fury), and in most cases they can also stack their block and dodge rate making the odds even higher (SW with shield, JC with Elder Fury, JC with Shield).

On the other hand, a WM can't improve his crit beyond whatever he gems. There are no abilities for a WM to improve his crit rate. Thus, it is arguable that whatever chance a WM has to crit with his snapcasted spell, the opponent (non-WM classes) always has an even higher chance to block and dodge the damage. Thus the damage aspect of Snapcast is actually pretty balanced since Snapcast doesn't improve chances of crit, or damage of the spell. The WM gains an instant cast but his opponents almost always have a higher chance to dodge/block than he can crit in any event.

But if you're insisting snapcast should only be used for the chance to land a negative status and suffer all the drawbacks of being dodged/blocked and unable to crit, i.e. it is no longer a damage tool but a utility tool, then my answer to that is that the cooldown and warm-up of snapcast must be halved so that a WM gets a chance to use it more than once a fight. We already suffer terribly to JC's juggernaut which can be used about 3 times in any fight where the players know what they are doing. If snapcast is going to be purely a negative status tool, it better be able to match up against juggernaut sans heroic will so that I can sneak negative statuses in between his cooldowns. At least let me use it twice a fight then. This has to be a logical answer to prevent upsetting the balance too much.
I apologize, Japster, for attempting to set up a strawman argument. You make some good points and like I said, with your implementation the only thing that I would take an issue with is a 100% kb.

Thinking on it, I dont believe that the problem is legitimately with snap cast anyways, snapcast is just the looking glass through which the shortcomings of the combat system are most glaring. As far as fight winning abilities go, it is the penultimate example; if your snapcasted incinerate crits, you win and if it is blocked you lose. This translates into 'if it crits your opponent thinks the ability is overpowered and if it is dodged or blocked you think it is nerfed too much'.

We have all had an instance come up like that. Now if this moment came up when both combatants are at 10% or less of their life total I dont think anyone (or at least as many) would have a big problem with this ability but the crucial, game changing moment can occur when people have 35-45% of their remaining hit points left. I think that is bad for business.

Crits themselves are too big. Dodge and block percentages are too high and players dont have enough control over their own characters. A little bit of randomness adds interest but turning a match into a game of dice cheapens the notion that we engage in battles of skill.

I have heard people say that crits are big because if they werent the battles would be too long. Well, giving people nuclear cruise missles for attacks isnt the answer either. We need tighter scaling, damage dealing and resolution needs to be normalized and our abilities need to land more often than they miss. If you didnt have to worry about your opponent dodging or blocking your attack 57% of the time you wouldnt need to land a crit for 14k to make an impact in the fight. I was just pulling a number out of thin air for illustration but the point is if we reduce the amount of times attacks completely fail then the outcomes that actually hit dont need to be so powerful.

I dont know, maybe some people enjoy fast fights with lucky streaks when you crit all of your abilities and the other person misses every attack. But I personally feel robbed when all my attacks miss and feel like my victory is cheapened when my opponents abilities are fully resisted and I dodge most of the hits.

There has to be a middle ground where we keep the randomness to a minimum and our combat choices matter more than what my virtual dice has rolled.

Anyways, I always enjoy other points of view. I find that I do just as much good (if not more) by sparking a debate as I do by attempting to solve a problem myself.

japster

ModeratorTue Sep 30, 2014 5:00 pm
Not going to quote you for sake of brevity, but I generally agree with your sentiments on fights being too fast and bursty at times.

But that's the way Venan claimed people wanted it. Apparently in the past hp stacking was too prevalent and powerful, and people were upset they couldn't beat 50k hp builds without 50k hp themselves. Thus Venan shifted the goalposts by scaling hp, allowing glass cannon builds to actually stand a chance.

As HP drops, crits become more pivotal. And crits are all about luck…so meh…majority wanted luck I suppose? I highly doubt Venan would backtrack now since their whole point (as I said earlier), was to allow glass cannon builds to be viable. The streakiness of wins is an intended effect of Venan's decision.

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Sep 30, 2014 5:07 pm
japster wrote:Not going to quote you for sake of brevity, but I generally agree with your sentiments on fights being too fast and bursty at times.

But that's the way Venan claimed people wanted it. Apparently in the past hp stacking was too prevalent and powerful, and people were upset they couldn't beat 50k hp builds without 50k hp themselves. Thus Venan shifted the goalposts by scaling hp, allowing glass cannon builds to actually stand a chance.

As HP drops, crits become more pivotal. And crits are all about luck…so meh…majority wanted luck I suppose? I highly doubt Venan would backtrack now since their whole point (as I said earlier), was to allow glass cannon builds to be viable. The streakiness of wins is an intended effect of Venan's decision.

You know Japster...I miss that significantly. It wasn't unheard of to have battles last 30-40 actions on average, and yes, occasionally you would get unlucky, but you could compensate over the range of the battle with better tactics. now, just like you said, one to two unlucky crits or resists and ..its over...just today I fought several people multiple times in a row...each outcome different then the last but the wins were always decided by a resist here or a crit or two there, etc...there is no time in the current battles to compensate for one or two bad rolls.

I still miss the 20 sec timers too...I was so against it when they changed that.

Longest battle I ever had was against Tiffy...65 actions. Now I am amazed if a fight goes past 10...

japster

ModeratorTue Sep 30, 2014 5:22 pm
Mithrid wrote:

You know Japster...I miss that significantly. It wasn't unheard of to have battles last 30-40 actions on average, and yes, occasionally you would get unlucky, but you could compensate over the range of the battle with better tactics. now, just like you said, one to two unlucky crits or resists and ..its over...just today I fought several people multiple times in a row...each outcome different then the last but the wins were always decided by a resist here or a crit or two there, etc...there is no time in the current battles to compensate for one or two bad rolls.

I still miss the 20 sec timers too...I was so against it when they changed that.

Longest battle I ever had was against Tiffy...65 actions. Now I am amazed if a fight goes past 10...

I miss those days too. I miss you in PvP too lol.

Totally agree about how tactics actually turned the fight around, balancing out the "luck" aspect. Forced players to make the right decisions and count the cooldowns. It rarely matters nowadays. Everything turns on the lucky resist or crit.

WMs with sword and shield were so OP back then…the WM OP complaints of today haven't played enough beta :lol:

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Sep 30, 2014 5:29 pm
japster wrote:

I miss those days too. I miss you in PvP too lol.

Oh I started PvPing again 2 weeks ago...but all that time off has left me with a puny mage. ;)
He needs to catch-up...I still don't have any T6 Gems much less PvP gear. My enchants are also behind the curve...I've also been collecting a lot of stats to try and decide if I can create a build that can overcome the RNG effects...not looking terribly promising. I am experimenting with new enchants and strategies as well...unfortunately the essence costs for experimenting with enchants is just plan ridiculous. (not to mention inventory limits) It may be awhile before you catch me up at masters level... :D That being said I'm having fun again.

As for back in the day, all 1H were OP compared to 2H...however I still think beta Justi had the advantage.

japster

ModeratorWed Oct 1, 2014 2:55 am
Mithrid wrote:
japster wrote:

I miss those days too. I miss you in PvP too lol.

Oh I started PvPing again 2 weeks ago...but all that time off has left me with a puny mage. ;)
He needs to catch-up...I still don't have any T6 Gems much less PvP gear. My enchants are also behind the curve...I've also been collecting a lot of stats to try and decide if I can create a build that can overcome the RNG effects...not looking terribly promising. I am experimenting with new enchants and strategies as well...unfortunately the essence costs for experimenting with enchants is just plan ridiculous. (not to mention inventory limits) It may be awhile before you catch me up at masters level... :D That being said I'm having fun again.

As for back in the day, all 1H were OP compared to 2H...however I still think beta Justi had the advantage.

I'm downgrading my might to about 20k ish to PvP there instead. PvP there is different from Masters league, and I think I can try new rotations/builds (like Icy Grasp -> Shattering Force). Tired of Masters really. Plus with the new t18 on the horizon and the lack of t18 PvP gear, PvP will never be properly balanced gear-wise at the top. I think it's more balanced to play at the low/middle range and involves less cost!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Oct 1, 2014 2:56 pm
Agree Japster, I'd say I've had far more fun down in Gold II scrapping with my 18-19k Spiricar than with main in Plat I/II. Matches are far fairer, the fights more interesting (not to mention shorter) and you don't have the eggshells feeling that one loss will take 3-4 wins (or whatever it works out as) to make up. Plus, if you get an opponent who is great and marmalises you, chances are the fight will be relatively short and less agonising.

So I'd recommend anyone in the higher leagues grab a lower toon and have some fun.
It would be a great thing if we could get a dev to comment on where they see pvp at as a whole, and if they could speculate on what kind of changes we could expect in the future well that would be icing on the proverbial cake.