Book of Heroes

Is two truly better than one? · page 2

If that's in response to what I said, I wasn't talking about you. I was talking about the people advocating shields. As far as weapon types go in this game here is the order as I see it.

2H > DW > dw dead fish + old cheese > unarmed > 1H + Shield

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Tue Jul 10, 2012 8:26 pm
Meian wrote:If that's in response to what I said, I wasn't talking about you. I was talking about the people advocating shields. As far as weapon types go in this game here is the order as I see it.

2H > DW > dw dead fish + old cheese > unarmed > 1H + Shield

Nice pecking order..

I see it as this.

2H > DW > Fist and Dirt > Dual Wielding Air > Using a sword but no shield (heroic) > Using nothing > Wearing a shield on your head > Shield
Fair enough. Shields are just awful. Back in like 1.1 2H weapons had a swing timer that pond scum laughed at for being slow. At that point 1H + Shield was fine. Then 2H weapons got a passive 25% haste buff but nothing was done with shields which were alreay bad just the other options were worse.
My justicar and mage alts are still using sword and shield from back then, but since both you and Gio say that's dumb, I'll switch them over at least for t10. :) 2H axe for the justicar, then?
The way I see it, yes speed is the key to killing without taking damage but if you can kill with one hit instead of 2, the advantage goes to 2h. I can kill kraken with one crit hit and all other bosses except trask in 2 hits (>7k damage). In combination with a stun/interupt I don't get hit at all (unless I am not paying attention). The key I have found is the crit% if I am unlucky with crit I have to hit bosses upto 4 times (I have max crit at 50%). If mages were to be allowed to go above the soft cap (50%) like shadow walkers (they can cap at 100%) then there would really be no contest. At the moment I still like my 2h weapon but would like it more with 100% crit :)
I made the switch with my original char. I do have a speed problem, but will be fixing that. When the multiple character upgrade came, I did little beyond dailys with him, and didn't get filthy rich. Transition from old equipment to new has been slow. One I get speed up, should be doing well. I have other justices that are doing well with 2h and decent speed. Not even maxed yet, no lv 25
dragonclan wrote:My shadow walker stacked haste & crit power. If you are using the two weapon fighting stance or sword & board with an SW and not one shooting creatures it's a gear, level, misplaced gem set up, or lack of understanding; when using your SW. I regularly critical hit for 2000+ damage before I got to 6250+ might. Now, at 7090+ might I crush things, including Emperor Trask, for 3000+ damage. That said, 2-handers might hit for more damage at a time. But a properly used 1-hander, in a skilled SW's hands is going to make a justicar, wielding a 2-hander, wish he/she was carrying a shield.

Those numbers don't mean too much without knowing what weapon you are using and the attack used to get the critical. My might is under 7k and with the T10 axe I can get just over 4500 crits on Trask with Brutal Strike. I've gone through the entire Trask fight including the mobs leading up to him without using a single health potion. Often all 3 trash mobs will die from a single Seismic Slash. 2h damage is better than 1h. You don't need speed if they are already dead.
When I posted, I did so humorously, since a SW can't use a 2-hander to fight with. Secondly, SW are fast to begin with, add up special abilities, gems, and trained (hero tokened abilities) & justicar are just slow. No offense ment. How long are your best attack timers? I can crank out 3 toxic blade attacks in no time for 3k+.
GioRGiO wrote:The way I see it, yes speed is the key to killing without taking damage but if you can kill with one hit instead of 2, the advantage goes to 2h. I can kill kraken with one crit hit and all other bosses except trask in 2 hits (>7k damage). In combination with a stun/interupt I don't get hit at all (unless I am not paying attention). The key I have found is the crit% if I am unlucky with crit I have to hit bosses upto 4 times (I have max crit at 50%). If mages were to be allowed to go above the soft cap (50%) like shadow walkers (they can cap at 100%) then there would really be no contest. At the moment I still like my 2h weapon but would like it more with 100% crit :)


My SW is about 93% crit chance with the buff, but I'm sure I can get it closer to 100 eventually. That is indeed a major advantage to playing a SW over any other class.

I've recently had the opportunity to run another player's characters and see how 2-H weapon works.

SW - not a choice, though you can arm with a slower, heavier hitting axe. Our lvl 25 SWs played much the same.

Justicer - I barely noticed the 2-H extra damage. What I did notice was the slowness, exaccerbated by his having 42% haste to my 45.something%. His Justicer got hit more often than mine using the same attack sequence.

Mage - OMG. I dislike my Mage for the extra button mashes I need to do each round, 6 vs 4 for most mobs on a SW or Justicer. The Mage lacks a mob pushback effect which the other have (I understand Time Void used to have this and it was removed), so they get hit more often by fast attackers like wolves and bats. This seems worse if the Mage is slowed by a 2-H weapon. I saw no difference in speed taking down bosses, except my sword wielding mage rarely takes damage.

In this discussion we've overlooked the fact that there are 2 choices for both 1-H and 2-H weapons for some classes. I am currently running a lvl 13 Justicer with an axe, because I got it for free at the end of a quest. Can't ignore the free stuff at that level.
Speed isn't really the issue on my Justicar. Got my haste maxxed pretty much and on runs like Helion and Zuur the trash go down in one to two hits unbuffed. If Seismic Slash crits they all go down in one blow and that attack is fast. My crit is also maxxed so that happens several times as I burn through my energy. Due to not having to buff and only taking one or two attacks to kill the trash I'm able to use up my energy very quickly. I don't see any need to be faster so why not maximize my damage. That is my primary reason to use a 2h weapon.

The main issue on Justicars is the blocking and dodging in the game. It is particularly bad on bosses and in Felmarsh. I've had mobs dodge 4 or 5 times in a row which is just a bit much in my opinion. I think it needs to be balanced a bit better or there needs to be some sort of anti-dodge mechanic. Justicars only have one pushback and every boss seems to be highly melee resistant. Out of my three characters the Justicar takes the biggest hit on bosses performance wise but that really has nothing to do with speed.

I also have a high level SW and WM. On a Helion run my Justicar is fastest through the trash, but it's about a tie on bosses between my mage and SW with my Justicar being slowest. SW is probably slightly faster than the mage due to less buffing/debuffing. The mage never misses though. The Justicar crits almost every hit and is quick but the occasional misses still slow things a little. It doesn't happen that often thankfully. My mage uses a staff and it is a bit slower but I like to maximize damage. Just my playstyle. I have a good rotation and don't get hit much. I ran all my energy out on my mage on Helion without getting hit once. It's just about knowing how to use the spells effectively. Speed isn't necessary to pull that off.