Book of Heroes

Is two truly better than one? · page 3

I agree, I've been working on all my alts to get them close enough in might to be comparable. Atm I have a lvl25 of each class, with justic (sword and shield) and sw (axe and sword) at ~8.5k might, my wm (2h staff) is ~12k might.
I have also found justic to be faster at mob killing, while my wm is fastest at bosses. My sw is probably overall my fastest char in raids such as CK because there are 2 phases of mobs and 2 bosses. The vallus on the other hand my wm is supreme (can kill vallus in one crit hit). I therefore prefer a 2h in a Mage, and a 1h on the other classes. The choice between 1h axe snd sword for me is sw axe and justic sword.
Meian wrote:Mage spell cast times are not affected by weapon speed.
...since when? Anything that causes weapon-based damage is affected by weapon speed, for all classes. The only things that aren't are buffs and debuffs.
Marney wrote:
Meian wrote:Mage spell cast times are not affected by weapon speed.
...since when? Anything that causes weapon-based damage is affected by weapon speed, for all classes. The only things that aren't are buffs and debuffs.

Nevermind, I thought it didn't. I remember testing that but I'm not sure why I got the wrong results.
I've just gone through the math, and it serms that once you're beyond around 150 bonus melee/spell-damage, faster weapons have a higher DPS output than slow weapons.

The reason for this is that bonus damage doesn't scale with attack speed. For Justicars that means that Brutal Strike (3) will do:
(Average Weapon Damage + Melee Bonus) * 1.6
Where Average Weapon Damage is (Minimum damage + Maximum Damage) / 2

For my Justicar it means that with Divine Power active (389 bonus melee damage) the damage output will be:
1.4 speed T11Axe: (400 + 389) * 1.6 = 1262
With max haste my attack speed is 0.7, so the DPS ends up at 1803

1.0 speed T11 sword: (250.5 + 389) * 1.6 = 1023
With max haste my attack speed is 0.5, so the DPS ends up at 2046.

Based on this I would clearly recommend you to go for the 1-h sword (for endgame), if your only concern is pure damage output.

However there are also other factors that determine how fast you kill things.
An argument against using a 1-hander could be that you also need to factor in the time the attack animation takes, and the time it takes to select a new skill.
Seeing that the 1-hander is faster, you would have to see more attack animations and select more attacks during a battle. This could mean that your actual time used to kill a boss is longer.
More time is what I found to be true with 1h weapons. The extra attacks needed to kill opponents negates the speed advantage. It also opens the player up to more counter attacks. No matter what you choose Justicars are slowest on bosses due to all the blocks and dodges and the lower crit chance. On trash the 2h Justicars in our guild are almost always fastest. SW's are also very fast and are fastest on bosses by a large margin.