Book of Heroes

Is two truly better than one?

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Mon Jul 2, 2012 11:59 pm
The duel is about to begin!

2 Handed weapons Vs. Mainhand + Offhand

2 handed : Slightly higher DPS
4x Gem Modifier

Mainhand
Lower cost, BARELY a dps difference,
2x gem modifier for both sword and shield, allowing diversity, allows shield or offhand Wep, for more defense or offense.





So can someone tell me, does 2H have a secret bonus or is it just underpowered?

TONIGHT_WE_DINE_IN_HELL

Tue Jul 3, 2012 7:38 am
In fact, no class that can carry two handed weapon have an alternation of main hand plus off hand weapon. SO there is no way that main plus off handed can contribute more dps than two handed weapon.
The option between those two style is about the same to choose one from defence and offence. And they differs A LOT.
The main difference is a possibility to have 8 active gems when using one handed weapon. So you can choose what to have: 4 stats with high modifier or a combination of 4+4 stats whith lesser modifier.
Criticals.

DPS isn't allowing for critical hits in the numbers. A crit with a 2-handed weapon is seriously damaging.

That said, I prefer to stick with 1-hand and have a shield (for Justicer or Mage) or offhand weapon (for Shadow Warrior), because it's quicker, and I'm all about hitting the opposition before it gets me.

I just went through a Cursed Keep raid, rotating between three characters, one of each type, and didn't take a single wound. Mages are particularly good fo this as their magic attacks can't be dodged or blocked (I think, at least I don't recall seeing it).

I'd like to get a 2-h weapon for the Justicer and Mage and see how it affects my timing, eventually. For now my attack sequence is working well, the enemies regularly drop dead swiftly, so why mess with it? My suspicion is I'd take more damage as well as dealing out more with 2-h; it'd be more of a gamble. Then again I have to regularly sell large potion by the crate load anyway, so maybe a 2-h would save me the bother.
<troll> SHIELDS ARE FOR PUSSIES </troll>
(i am a justiciar)
My 20% haste allow me to have a 1.05 attack speed with a 2H sword, and the damage output is quite nice. The 1H is fast, okay, but the damage are not as good, like in a 1v3, the 2H can in one shot making it a 1v2, which a 1H can't.

As said before, the 8 gems can be a +
I've tried it both ways and 2h just seems better to me. With big hits I can 1 shot many enemies who would otherwise get a crack at me during my second swing with a 1h weapon. The crits are just downright nasty. With haste I don't have any speed issues.
I have 3 justicars. Lv 25 with 1 hand and shield, and he doesnt do as well as my (then) lv 22 shadow walker. Other 2 are lv 23, and do better with 2 hand weapon. Will make the switch when I get enough valor for lv 25
My shadow walker stacked haste & crit power. If you are using the two weapon fighting stance or sword & board with an SW and not one shooting creatures it's a gear, level, misplaced gem set up, or lack of understanding; when using your SW. I regularly critical hit for 2000+ damage before I got to 6250+ might. Now, at 7090+ might I crush things, including Emperor Trask, for 3000+ damage. That said, 2-handers might hit for more damage at a time. But a properly used 1-hander, in a skilled SW's hands is going to make a justicar, wielding a 2-hander, wish he/she was carrying a shield.
DW vs 2H is fine. Both have their upsides and downsides but since there isn't a class that can do both it's a moot point.

What impresses me is how little people seem to know about the game mechanics. At this point in the game anyone that actually thinks Shields are viable doesn't have a clue as to what they are doing.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Mon Jul 9, 2012 11:32 pm
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:The duel is about to begin!

2 Handed weapons Vs. Mainhand +Offhand

2 handed : Slightly higher DPS
4x Gem Modifier

Mainhand
Lower cost, BARELY a dps difference,
2x gem modifier for both sword and shield, allowing diversity, allows shield or offhand Wep, for more defense or offense.





So can someone tell me, does 2H have a secret bonus or is it just underpowered?


Can I just say I said this in my first two days of playing, so if anyone else wants to act like I'm an idiot idc okay?