Book of Heroes

Community Design Challenge! · page 25

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Apr 18, 2016 8:23 am
GettinDerpyWithIt wrote:In order to make mercs give a certain amount of energy to a raid you could have them "pay" that amount of energy into a raid-specific escrow account prior to entering and then they draw from that account while raiding. If they leave the raid prior to using the escow energy, they lose it when the raid finishes. If the raid completes successfully and they still have banked energy, it might be up to the raid guild as to whether the merc deserves the energy back. If they kept hitting, fine but if they just skunked or lost connection, sorry.

I quite like that. If the raid is setting the limit I like the idea of a (for example) 30e minimum commitment. You pay the e and get access to the raid. Doesn't really stop skunking though. I'd still probably prefer a minimum rpp limit for the raid. If you don't reach it, you get no rewards. If you don't reach it within a certain window, you are auto-kicked from the raid, receive zero rewards and zero e back. The raid still benefits from the hits though.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Mon Apr 18, 2016 1:26 pm
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:Is this fair to someone who gets in on the tail end of a raid?
At that point, the smart raid host has removed the minimum energy/rpp constraints... Plus a smart merc wouldn't commit to that much energy/rpp when a raid is almost over. :0)
But if you just have a few left over e to use up and a raid is close to finishing maybe they could use your help to finish or even achieve gold. Should you not get the reward for helping out? Admittedly, this would be rare, but it does happen.

If the host removes the constraints, then the point is moot.

I understand the issue and personally try to never enter a raid without a full compliment of e to contribute. It is frustrating for someone to occupy a valuable merc spot and not contribute to the success of the raid.
other way to slove this raid issue is
1) guild should start merging if u all can finish a raid
2) players should stop creating guilds n just join one instead. ( i think there are more guilds than active players)

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Tue Apr 19, 2016 6:00 am
_Raiden wrote:other way to slove this raid issue is
1) guild should start merging if u all can finish a raid
2) players should stop creating guilds n just join one instead. ( i think there are more guilds than active players)
So you mean do away with mercs altogether.
There does seem to be a lot of small guilds. Nearly 9000 guilds total.

Mercing is a major part of the games appeal. I personally enjoy interacting with the members of various guilds. That would be a major loss to the game.
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:There does seem to be a lot of small guilds. Nearly 9000 guilds total.

You mean dead guilds. I bet 7000 of them do not have a single active player in them.

Mercing is a major part of the games appeal. I personally enjoy interacting with the members of various guilds. That would be a major loss to the game.

You probably weren't around during the free merc era 3+ years ago (Raiden was). We used to have to much more interaction.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Tue Apr 19, 2016 11:13 am
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:
Why doesn't Venan clear out inactive guilds?
???? ?ut it on the list.

The "free merc" era... Was that prior to guild loyalty?