Book of Heroes

Community Design Challenge! · page 27

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Fri Apr 22, 2016 6:07 am
Ooh, beholders! They'd be a good class of enemies to add. They could have attacks like mesmer eyes, lazy eyes, cold stare, if looks could kill...
Bbbb wrote:Illy only saw one failed merger? Meanwhile, I can only name one that was completely successful (HJ's formation). Out of the dozens of others I've seen they ranged from Meh to epic fail.

I do not consider an absorption of an already failed guild into another guild (Spoon to Fizz) a merger.

Fizzbears have combined with quite a few guilds (before the spoons merger).... not all of them dead. But yes, B4 is right, there have been a crap load of failed mergers....lol

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Apr 22, 2016 4:41 pm
Bbbb wrote:Illy only saw one failed merger? Meanwhile, I can only name one that was completely successful (HJ's formation). Out of the dozens of others I've seen they ranged from Meh to epic fail.

I do not consider an absorption of an already failed guild into another guild (Spoon to Fizz) a merger.

Doesn't really matter what you consider it, it's still a merger :) there were many others before that and even earlier when our guild merged into Fizz. All successful.

This is always a topic that comes out polarised beyond reality IMO. Just by watching the boards you could see as time went by many successful mergers. Some of those guilds are no longer about either, but the guild concept is probably at the end of its life now. Raids are simply too big and active player numbers too small.

The main point was that hanging on to a largely dead guild where multiple players are running 5+ toons out of nostalgia doesn't really help the active players still there. Makes much more sense to merge into an active guild or find one to merge into yours.

(Disclaimer: Not referring to any guild or persons in particular).

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Apr 22, 2016 4:49 pm
Lord_Garic wrote:I don't believe Ilyana is bitter. Perception is in the eye of the beholder...

It's the Internet, where criticism is countered with personal attacks and people think there is no objectivity ;)

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Fri Apr 22, 2016 7:01 pm
Let's all support public raids!

Public CV needs 15 more hitters to make Gold... Silver... Bronze... Please???
Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:Let's all support public raids!

Public CV needs 15 more hitters to make Gold... Silver... Bronze... Please???

CV is the worst raid ever.. probably tied with HM
Jumper wrote:
CV is the worst raid ever.. probably tied with HM

CV, HM and VG are all the same raid anyway.

Ever? Don't think so. Raids that were much worse:

1. Toon limited KFS when we were all underpowered and dying a lot. After one attempt, I stated I would never run that raid again.
2. The original WoF. The three phases of Trask was so long and boring.
3. 6 hr Hellion
4. 6 hr Overseer - I remember spending 5 hr and 40 mins on this raid one time. Another guild had a meltdown when they failed by a couple kills.
5. The Shadow Comes - There were about 10 of us who didn't hate the raid with a passion. And two former players cheesing this for hero score is why we have P1 mobs on OS raids....

However, none of those have existed in 3 years.
The difference with the other raids is neither CV nor HM were top raids. They just sucked. Also note that they changed the other raids to fix the suckiness.... sucking not being enough, suckers keep sucking at those sucky raids. I hope the suckination will soon be done, cause I suck at using other words than suck.