Book of Heroes

Community Design Challenge! · page 26

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:
Why doesn't Venan clear out inactive guilds?
???? ?ut it on the list.

The "free merc" era... Was that prior to guild loyalty?

yes. prior to 1.6.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Apr 19, 2016 1:00 pm
_Raiden wrote:other way to slove this raid issue is
1) guild should start merging if u all can finish a raid
2) players should stop creating guilds n just join one instead. ( i think there are more guilds than active players)

100% agree. There are a lot of guilds now that are hanging on, raiding at a much lower level (and only then through running 5+ toons each) than the might of their players suggests they should be and where the big toons rarely raid at GV level except as mercs. Might as well merge with a similarly affected guild and raid at a higher level. Yeah you might have put a lot of effort into the guild, but if you're that concerned, find someone to merge into yours. Seen multiple mergers and only one that didn't work, and that was only because of a weird nostalgia the players had for their old guild. So they went back, and the guild vanished from the top of the boards.
Bring back the backgrounds and weapons from the Pvp Beta. We can use medals to buy them. So the players that didn't join until after the Pvp Beta can still be able to get them since it isn't fair to the ones who didn't join until after Beta.
-Rose <33
Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:
Why doesn't Venan clear out inactive guilds?
???? ?ut it on the list.

The "free merc" era... Was that prior to guild loyalty?


To be honest guild loyalty was the begaining of the end for boh. It killed the community interaction and that was the start of all this crap "skunk" mercing issues.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Wed Apr 20, 2016 8:28 am
_Raiden wrote:
Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:
I_am_Shadowspawn wrote:
Why doesn't Venan clear out inactive guilds?
???? ?ut it on the list.

The "free merc" era... Was that prior to guild loyalty?


To be honest guild loyalty was the begaining of the end for boh. It killed the community interaction and that was the start of all this crap "skunk" mercing issues.
Well, I suspect that some skunk mercking is due to the achievement of participating in X raids. Anyone remember... Oh, what was his name... wasn't it KRONAZ?

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Wed Apr 20, 2016 8:33 am
Illy_the_Red wrote:Seen multiple mergers and only one that didn't work, and that was only because of a weird nostalgia the players had for their old guild. So they went back, and the guild vanished from the top of the boards.
I have been part of 5 guild mergers and they all failed because the top guild always expects the lower guild to send their top toons and never supports the remaining toons that can't raid that high so the players end up adrift while the lower guild withers or are kicked to the wind when the lower guild closes.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Thu Apr 21, 2016 8:16 am
Rezel wrote:Feeder guilds and mergers are very different.
Yep. Which one do you think I was talking about?

Actually now that I think about it, one of the "mergers" was billed as a feeder guild situation but the top guild supported *one* raid of the supposed feeder guild then abandoned it entirely. Yes, I'm talking about you, EL.

But we digress...

Community Design, anyone?
Illy only saw one failed merger? Meanwhile, I can only name one that was completely successful (HJ's formation). Out of the dozens of others I've seen they ranged from Meh to epic fail.

I do not consider an absorption of an already failed guild into another guild (Spoon to Fizz) a merger.