Book of Heroes

"Guild Loyalty" vs "Mercy Mercing" · page 2

Darkhorse wrote:I like where Falos and Niko's heads are at! ;)


I suppose I could like this idea ;)

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Apr 16, 2013 12:13 pm
I'm a relatively new player (December 2012), so can't comment on how things were. The way the game is at the moment, there is little incentive to join a guild permanently when you can get the main rewards (valour, tokens) by simply waiting for someone to start the raid you want then advertise for help. I like the fact that I have joined guilds and worked up sufficient raid time and trust to become a vet or officer. Mercing threatens this if too many become mercs as opposed to joining guilds. I merced for a while and found it a lazy way out. If I can get the best kit that way, why would I ever want to join a guild?

Guilds should be friendly, social places, not just a bunch of people getting valour. Raising the cap means more potential members for the guild and therefore a higher turnout to raids. At the moment mercing is too easy an alternative even for members with 'home' guilds. Raising it also deals with the problem of maxed-out guilds, something we've also run into. At the moment I'd struggle to move up to the Captain-level guilds because they are usually maxed out. It also means some guilds will be able to merge and possibly run raids of differing levels within the same guild (the lower level raids finding they always have an easy source of help if theirs stalls too much).

Like Darkhorse said, nobody's saying 'mercy mercing' is dead. I'd just like to see it go back to being a game about progression as a social group rather than progressing the easiest way possible.
Ilyana wrote:At the moment I'd struggle to move up to the Captain-level guilds because they are usually maxed out.

Lots of the CV guilds have space. In fact, maybe all. TCG is one of the most full and Japster is running member recruitment ads in global. On the merc side, most of the day you can find open slots in CV raids.

It also means some guilds will be able to merge and possibly run raids of differing levels within the same guild (the lower level raids finding they always have an easy source of help if theirs stalls too much).

Good point.
I'd just like to see it go back to being a game about progression as a social group rather than progressing the easiest way possible.

When I had played for only 4 months, I might have agreed with you but not now after watching what happens to most of the social groups in this game. Most guilds die or vastly change due to attrition, turnover, mergers, GM changes and even people becoming bored of chatting with each other. Yes, there are a couple of counterexamples (e.g. KOTOR), but well over 99% of all guilds that ever existed (hundreds or thousands have been deleted) have vastly changed or completely died. If you list all the guilds that in 6 months haven't had a major GM change, didn't merge, kept over 50% of their membership and are moderately active, it would be a very short list.

I have no issue with guilds but I do not see them as inherently better than full-time mercs or vice versa.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Apr 17, 2013 9:58 am
Lots of the CV guilds have space. In fact, maybe all. TCG is one of the most full and Japster is running member recruitment ads in global. On the merc side, most of the day you can find open slots in CV raids.

The top five guilds had 9 spaces between them last time I checked. Not exactly a lot of give there (but not full either). I still think expanding to 100 will help multiple players move up permanently if they want to. This doesn't take into account the legions of players removed from their guilds (it does happen) in order to make way for mercs. This shouldn't be necessary. You shouldn't get kicked just because you weren't at the last raid, or went on holiday etc. The guilds need to be bigger to accomodate the players that want to be there.
Most guilds die or vastly change due to attrition, turnover, mergers, GM changes and even people becoming bored of chatting with each other.

Yes, it happens. I don't think this is a flaw, it's part of what keeps guilds going. Some wither and die while others continue and improve via natural evolution. Most people are hostile to change but that does not make it a bad thing. A lot of the deleted guilds would've been dead anyway, there always seems to be legions of them.

Personally my experience regarding mercs isn't of roving bands of altruistic characters who descend on dying raids and then leave so they don't eat into the guild's valour. It's of people who jump into the raids they see advertised to get valour as quickly and easily as possible. It may not be your experience, but it is for a lot of others.
Ilyana wrote:
The top five guilds had 9 spaces between them last time I checked.

You can't trust that way of counting. That includes a lot of mercs - probably 5-10 per guild on average. Heck, I've seen Spoons vary between 20 and 60 members on the same day.

Personally my experience regarding mercs isn't of roving bands of altruistic characters who descend on dying raids

I have never said that they are altruistic. I'm sure there are a handful of those but not most. Back in the fall, there was a lot more altruistic mercing going on but that was because guilds were doing favors saving each others' raids. The need went away with the influx of new players with 1.5.

and then leave so they don't eat into the guild's valour. It's of people who jump into the raids they see advertised to get valour as quickly and easily as possible. It may not be your experience, but it is for a lot of others.

If the guilds are advertising, they want the merc support. It is a win-win situation for both sides. If guilds do not want mercs, they can keep them out. It's not like the guilds are forced to take on mercs. Just turn off auto accept and manually take in who you want. If you don't like mercs eating into your guild's valor, then find a closed door guild.

At the top level, I suspect that TCG, KOTOR and maybe others will run as closed door guilds for the most part once 1.6 comes out.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Apr 17, 2013 1:27 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Ilyana wrote:

If the guilds are advertising, they want the merc support. It is a win-win situation for both sides. If guilds do not want mercs, they can keep them out. It's not like the guilds are forced to take on mercs. Just turn off auto accept and manually take in who you want. If you don't like mercs eating into your guild's valor, then find a closed door guild.

At the end of the day, what Bbbb has said here is all that matters..don't like mercs, then don't use them or don't allow them. No one is forcing you to use them if your a guild or be one if your a player.

Its same argument as the Onslaught vrs Regular raids debate. If you don't like one or prefer the other, that is great, but don't ask Venan to eliminate one or the other, it is a personal preference for a style of play.

That being said, I do like the idea of rewarding guild loyalty, but I also do not think people should concern themselves with trying to punish or eliminate a style (aka Merc) of play in which other players find enjoyment.
Mithrid wrote: If you don't like one or prefer the other, that is great, but don't ask Venan to eliminate one or the other, it is a personal preference for a style of play.

That being said, I do like the idea of rewarding guild loyalty, but I also do not think people should concern themselves with trying to punish or eliminate a style (aka Merc) of play in which other players find enjoyment.
And that is all that really needs to be said.
-M
I'm pleased to see that "pure" raids will get a bonus, but one that isn't so huge that GMs have to pick poison between risk or low payout.