Book of Heroes

"Guild Loyalty" vs "Mercy Mercing"

I have grabbed my response to another post and re post it here because with 1.6 coming and Guild Loyalty looming so highly on the horizon, I feel this needs to be brought to Venan's attention.
This is a case of 'if it isn't broken, don't fix it:
With all due respect:
MegMasters wrote:Rivalries that deter merc'ing are irrelevant because merc'ing was never intended. The fact that you are free to roam from guild to guild reaping rewards is already stupid. There is no incentive for loyalty when you can just rejoin at any time and instantly regain your guild's favor bonuses, continuing to raid like you'd never left. If rivalries discourage this, it's for the better.

If this is how you view mercs and how you think mercs work in BoH you have not been playing in the same universe that we have. Either that or you have had some phenomenally bad luck and mercing with the wrong sorts of people. A huge part of the BoH community works around the 'Mercy Merc'-ing principles and examples set up by top guilds like the folks of HJ and it contributes a great deal to the community spirit of the game. Wherein the guild wanting to 'Mercy Merc' monitors Global for SOS calls, and people at the guild respond when a guild needs help because a raid has stalled out somewhere in the middle. The guild sends their own guild members and friends over to give the failing raid a hand and helps the guild in question finish the raid, and everyone has a better game experience because of it.

These mercy missions are not rare, and before you jump to the conclusion that they are not altruistic because of the valour pay out, I have witnessed and indeed participated in Mercy missions where the group or person(s) doing the mercing part before the end of the raid so the Guild in question can enjoy the extra valour. This small aspect of the game is yet another one of the unique things I have encountered in BoH, and I believe that it contributes a LOT to the very unique community spirit you find in this game. If the ability to so this were suddenly for whatever reason taken away, BoH would find itself very much worse off for it, as I can personally admit, this builds a huge amount of goodwill and adds greatly to the gameplay. There is nothing like the rush of coming in to rescue a baby guild's raid and leaving before the clock ticks over to finish. Allowing them the benefit of the extra valour and the success of the raid. As a very wise player and mentor of mine once said "a failed raid serves no one."
-M
venan can solve it very easy. guild loyality system will be as described, just without reset when out to merc.
then while raiding with your guild u accumulating loyality points and enjoy benefits like valor. and when mercing u don't have benefits but also Dont loosing loyality progress.
energy addition can be solved by adding energy only when joining ur guild raid and not for farming for example. or just starting with 600 rpp.
Disable guild creation.

If you proceed with the current blueprints, population division needs to be stopped, or the accessibility dramatically reduced. Surely a gigantic GS cost hike sounds agreeable?

Too many massively-multis have had low creation barriers, which is poor design if in-game results are dependant on full, synchronous guilds. Wave count demand WILL be too high for current roster sizes, and even if the implied cap raise (60->100) is true, it doesn't actually fill slots. Very few (if any) guilds handle the demanding activity/coordination of wave counts seen in anything near endgame ("real") raids purely on their own; they are the exception to the rule if they even exist.

Phrased differently, TLDR: global is full of "LFM! please hurry!", not "LFG".

Merc work from both freelancers and full alliances isn't just convenient, it's necessary. Several control switches are available, but increased roster cap is not one of them unless you magically double the current BoH player population. Possible solutions to the death of mercing:

- Reduce wave count demand
- Increase raid durations
- Develop incentivized (ie power score merged) guild fusion

But these treat a symptom; Ideally, a good design will not penalize merc'ing and will sustain the current desirable social aspect. This cannot be overstated - drawbacks in loot, energy stock/generation, loyalty progress, etc that are inflicted will stopper the flow of critical merc trade. But I'm not saying the perks themselves will destroy mercing - careful design of floating energy, restored perks, and persistent loyalty score (subject to limited departure and return) will allow both the presence of (a) the intended sense of home and permance associated with a clan, and (b) the wider sense of game community and alliance as described by Magdalene. It's good example of a full-scale social element rarely seen in MMOs - it's not easy to reproduce, Venan. You may not realize what you've got till it's gone.
Boiled it.

Raid clears = online players
Clan roster != online players
Global chat = online players
Another possibility (someone posted on FB) is a small penalty to guild loyalty for raiding elsewhere, but not a complete reset to zero. This makes the penalty for mercy mercing small.

One wonders how this might affect GS burning. Either:
1) without mercy mercs to rescue raids, guild members will have to burn more GS to complete raids.
2) without the possibility of mercy mercs, guild members will be less willing to risk burning GS in a raid that has a chance of failing.

Darkhorse

Site AdminSun Apr 14, 2013 10:47 am
You should probably wait until you see preview "Part 2" before you pass judgement. Who said mercy mercing was dead? ;)

japster

ModeratorSun Apr 14, 2013 10:48 am
Darkhorse wrote:You should probably wait until you see preview "Part 2" before you pass judgement. Who said mercy mercing was dead? ;)

Hurray! =) Could we like...get updates NOWWWW :P PLEASEEEE
<begin speculation>
Suppose a guild has the ability to "go global" with their raid. A guild could post their struggling raid to a board where any character from any guild can help. The penalty for such may be reduced reward (max silver level for example) and fewer power and prestige points.
<end speculation>

Kinda makes my new thread irrelevant.
Fspoo_NikoNarf wrote:Suppose a guild has the ability to "go global" with their raid.
In-game feature for what we have to do by mouth sounds like a very real QoL upgrade and is worth looking into, imo.