Book of Heroes

"Guild Loyalty" vs "Mercy Mercing" · page 4

japster

ModeratorSun Apr 21, 2013 2:22 am
Bbbb wrote:Japster's explanation is close but slightly off. A raid that has 55 slots,the guild then decides that up to 10 slots may be used by mercs. However, members can take those merc slots as well. This was explained in a reply by one of the developers in another thread.

Oh ok...I must have missed that reply. So just to ensure proper understanding, the only reason to change merc slots is to limit the amount of mercs coming in when necessary? After all if members will always fill up merc slots that are available if the member allocated slots are full, then there is no harm in starting a raid with a generous merc slot allocation and tuning it down if needed?
Falos wrote:I'm pleased to see that "pure" raids will get a bonus, but one that isn't so huge that GMs have to pick poison between risk or low payout.

I have to agree. My guild will mercy merc if asked, and if its for baby guilds I have seen my members leave before the end of the raid, and stay for higher level raids. We follow HJ examples of both, and since they tend to be top guild, I don't see how altruistic or win=win mercing is a thing that shouldn't be encouraged or penalized. If you don't like it, as others before have posted, you don't need to either encourage it or participate. Those that do, shouldn't have to at a price because some don't like to do it.

-M
With 1.6 and the ability to merc while staying in your home guild... will there be a way to "exit" a raid in the mercy merc fashion? Since you are still in your home guild, there may not be anything to "leave"
TCG_japster wrote:
Oh ok...I must have missed that reply. So just to ensure proper understanding, the only reason to change merc slots is to limit the amount of mercs coming in when necessary?

Correct
After all if members will always fill up merc slots that are available if the member allocated slots are full, then there is no harm in starting a raid with a generous merc slot allocation and tuning it down if needed?

Well, the harm is that if a wave of mercs come in and take all the slot allocation that your members could be locked out the raid. I have always thought the other strategy was better, start with a small merc slot allocation and expand it if members don't show for the raid.
I'd be all for a Guild Loyalty rate, maybe it could be used to give long term guild members a bonus, like a bit more silver per drop or something. Mercing sounds unnessicary, if your guild isnt up to beating a specific raid, maybe you shouldnt be trying to beat it yet, farm the other raids or level or gear up a bit more. Why should a guild that isnt ready get the rewards for someone else's work? Farm gems, enchants, and gear and then when your guild is ready it will progress.
Spartanmerc wrote:I'd be all for a Guild Loyalty rate, maybe it could be used to give long term guild members a bonus, like a bit more silver per drop or something. Mercing sounds unnessicary, if your guild isnt up to beating a specific raid, maybe you shouldnt be trying to beat it yet, farm the other raids or level or gear up a bit more. Why should a guild that isnt ready get the rewards for someone else's work? Farm gems, enchants, and gear and then when your guild is ready it will progress.

It works both ways spartan. Sometimes people like to do lower level raids too that their guild is too high for. There's plenty of reasons why mercing happens. But that's a whole different discussion.
I'd like to see something a bit more expansive, like alliance rewards . We have 4 guilds in our alliance because we can't fit every one in one guild.