Book of Heroes

"Guild Loyalty" vs "Mercy Mercing" · page 3

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Apr 18, 2013 6:56 am
At the end of the day, what Bbbb has said here is all that matters..don't like mercs, then don't use them or don't allow them. No one is forcing you to use them if your a guild or be one if your a player.

Making it sound like I was anti-merc, which I'm not. I and many other players are quite capable of allowing or not allowing them. Venan has identified the problem with the mercing phenomenon and is taking action to address it without outlawing it completely. The newest update should restore some semblance of balance. Diverting though talking about whether we are pro- or anti-merc is, the main issue is that the current way of things is skewed towards mercs and is going to be fixed.
I have never said that they are altruistic.

Intentional or not, that was the picture you were painting. As you say, the reality is somewhat different.
Mithrid wrote:
If you don't like one or prefer the other, that is great, but don't ask Venan to eliminate one or the other, it is a personal preference for a style of play.

That being said, I do like the idea of rewarding guild loyalty, but I also do not think people should concern themselves with trying to punish or eliminate a style (aka Merc) of play in which other players find enjoyment.
And that is all that really needs to be said.
-M

Again, I don't think anybody is asking for it to be outlawed, just balanced out. Sometimes things grow and evolve in different directions to those envisaged. This is a needed update, not an excuse to bash a whole subsection of the game's players.

I think the 'mercy-mercers', however many of them there still are, will not be penalised by this update and neither will mercs as a subgroup. If it leads to more closed-door guilds, so be it, I don't personally see that as an issue if there is still an easy way to recruit mercs if that guild wants/needs to.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Apr 18, 2013 6:58 am
I'm pleased to see that "pure" raids will get a bonus, but one that isn't so huge that GMs have to pick poison between risk or low payout.

Exactly.
One more side of things to bring up is provided no other nerfs taking place... mercing just got easier. Now rather than having to sift through global to do it, we just need to click the button and boom, take our pick. So everyone complaining this is an anti-merc thing, I don't know... might make life as a merc more bearable while also bringing back a bit more guild unity ;)
Oda_tc5k_Idaten wrote:One more side of things to bring up is provided no other nerfs taking place... mercing just got easier. Now rather than having to sift through global to do it, we just need to click the button and boom, take our pick. So everyone complaining this is an anti-merc thing, I don't know... might make life as a merc more bearable while also bringing back a bit more guild unity ;)


Actually, I think most top rank guild will not open raid to mercs if they have enough member's after 1.6 (with 100 members limit), Mercs probably only found raid in lower rank guild as they have the need to ask for help
Tiffy wrote:
Oda_tc5k_Idaten wrote:One more side of things to bring up is provided no other nerfs taking place... mercing just got easier. Now rather than having to sift through global to do it, we just need to click the button and boom, take our pick. So everyone complaining this is an anti-merc thing, I don't know... might make life as a merc more bearable while also bringing back a bit more guild unity ;)


Actually, I think most top rank guild will not open raid to mercs if they have enough member's after 1.6 (with 100 members limit), Mercs probably only found raid in lower rank guild as they have the need to ask for help

Hmm... didn't think about it that way. You're right, that could prove problematic. Oh well, I guess no way to know until it happens.
Unless I misread something, I think that the extra 40 spots will be merc spots - or did I just imagine that bit?

japster

ModeratorSat Apr 20, 2013 3:24 pm
Asandir wrote:Unless I misread something, I think that the extra 40 spots will be merc spots - or did I just imagine that bit?

You imagined that bit. They have yet to decide/release to us how many slots each raid will be given. Merc slots are for guilds to choose.

So if Venan sets that a Vallus raid can only have a maximum of 55 raiders, then guilds are free to allocate 30 slots to members and 25 to mercs. Or they could allocate 45 slots to members and 10 to mercs. It's their choice. The allocation between mercs and members may be changed anytime during the raid (but I assume that you can't reduce the slot allocation to lesser than the number of mercs currently in the raid) and the raid slot limit is kept constant.
I don't want to speak for all SPOONs, since I am a relatively new spoon, following the merger of one of the original top 5 guilds, Fairy Tail, but the SPOONs guild was built on being a welcoming place for mercs and a fun place to chat. Since mercs will have access to guild chat, and the SPOON ideal is to maximize fun (and chat) rather than maximize power, I find it likely SPOONs will continue welcoming mercs in 1.6
TCG_japster wrote:
Asandir wrote:Unless I misread something, I think that the extra 40 spots will be merc spots - or did I just imagine that bit?

You imagined that bit. They have yet to decide/release to us how many slots each raid will be given. Merc slots are for guilds to choose.

So if Venan sets that a Vallus raid can only have a maximum of 55 raiders, then guilds are free to allocate 30 slots to members and 25 to mercs. Or they could allocate 45 slots to members and 10 to mercs. It's their choice. The allocation between mercs and members may be changed anytime during the raid (but I assume that you can't reduce the slot allocation to lesser than the number of mercs currently in the raid) and the raid slot limit is kept constant.

Thanks japster
Japster's explanation is close but slightly off. A raid that has 55 slots,the guild then decides that up to 10 slots may be used by mercs. However, members can take those merc slots as well. This was explained in a reply by one of the developers in another thread.