Book of Heroes

Blacklist Deadbeat Mercs · page 6

frybender wrote:You have to appeal to venan's strong pride and sensibility in order to get this feature. Lets say we make it 10 gold shields to kick a merc out. Or maybe have a Guild perks type of thing. For only 100 gold shields guilds get the ability to kick mercs and other perks for the month. This keeps Venan's pockets filled and members happy then.

Absolutely not. To have to pay to have the option not to be skunked by bad players very quickly becomes "pay or be skunked".
Allomancer wrote:
Example Additional Requirements:
1. Minimum might and/or level. This could prevent mercs who are relatively weak and therefore might decide not to contribute in more difficult phases.

If the min-mights were right, this wouldn't be as much of an issue.

2. Current energy. This would prevent those mercs who join with no energy and only contribute whatever pittance they regen during the raid, assuming they even stick around. The requirement could be a percentage of the player's maximum energy instead of a number so people without maximum loyalty/sigils would not be penalized.

Back when I was doing my top 5 runs, I frequently entered raids with 2e and would end up with a top 3 placement. I'm not the only one - I bet I can name at least 50 more people who do this. Disagree with this completely.

3. Not currently in another raid. This one is self explanatory, but should be accompanied by an option for the merc to leave the raid if the kills per minute needed to finish the raid reaches a preset number, which could be a different number depending on the raid.

I've had the following situation. I wanted a PM. Couldn't find one, but found an open CV. Then later a PM opened up. What I did is that I made sure I dumped at least a whole bar in the CV before I started burning in the PM. Some people might disagree with that behavior, but I think I'm fulfilling the implicit merc contract.

4. Recent rpp in raids. This rating could be adjusted slightly based on the merc's starting energy and their total time in the raid, and averaged over a period of time like a week. Obviously this would be more difficult to implement than ideas 1-3, but it would be the most useful option to have.

I think this is too complex.

Those are my main ideas, but a huge list of more minor options could be provided, like:
-Home guild raid contribution.
-% of merced raids the player comments in the host guild's chat.
-recent online time per day
-recent energy used per day
-join date
-has Venan account
-minimum OR maximum number of merced raids in the past day/week/whatever.

I think you will find no correlation between any of those factors and how much RPP is done.
[quote="Allomancer"]Example Additional Requirements:

Those are my main ideas, but a huge list of more minor options could be provided, like:
-Home guild raid contribution.
-% of merced raids the player comments in the host guild's chat.
-recent online time per day
-recent energy used per day


I am opposed to several of these. I have had toons that belonged to dying guilds, guilds that changed to raids I could not do or were a waste to do, and guilds that raided at times I could not make. Those toons merced while I looked for a new guild. Home guild raid contribution could get me banned even though most would probably say I'm an excellent merc.

Recent online time or energy used per day can easily be skewed by busy real life time. You might finally have time to hit all day and find yourself banned or limited because you spent the last week working 12+ hour days, which I sometimes have to do.
I think Venan should use the following logic and make it so merc slots doin't get counted unless the following thresholds are met. 1) the toon needs to earn RPP equivalent to 5 or 10 hits for the raid. 2) the first threshold needs to be met within 20 mins. 3) the thresholds are removed for the last 50 hits of the raid to accommodate late comers. This way a slot is only held for 20 min for one hit wonders, late comers are not an issue, and we don't have to worry about reporting or kicking them out.