Lots of good ideas here.
I'm not sure about applying timescales to the blacklist, it seems unnecessarily complicated and adds an extra level of administration, both on the database and for the guild. The individuals involved have been acting like this for a long time in most cases, and have had plenty of time to understand that their behaviour is not appreciated - yet they continue. If they want to turn over a new leaf and play nicely, fine, but let them contact the guilds that have said "no" and ask to be removed from the list, rather than effectively just giving them a time-out. This keeps the membership control with the guild, which is the point of all this, AND keeps implementation as simple as possible.
I would prefer the list not be timed based either, I'm just trying to think of any possible Venan objections.
If venan is scared of hurting people's feelings, jus make the guild invisible to the blacklisted people so they wouldn't even know the raid was going on.
Ñütèllå_Wølf_ôf_Dréâms wrote:I would prefer the list not be timed based either, I'm just trying to think of any possible Venan objections.
Quite agree, Nutella. I just wish they'd tell us what their objections actually
are so we know what arguments to counter...
Nice idea about making the raids they're blacklisted from invisible Jumper, though it could lead to confusion and / or drama in Global etc if a guild ads for a raid which one person can't see and queries and... Bleh... Plus the technical aspect of implementing would be more involved. Maybe remove the "Join" button from view for blacklisted mercs? Might be easier and less "offensive" than pressing Join and getting a "SORRY!!! You're on THE LIST!!" message?
DreamingDæmon wrote: pressing Join and getting a "SORRY!!! You're on THE LIST!!" message?
hahahah no way! this is hilarious!
Jumper wrote:DreamingDæmon wrote: pressing Join and getting a "SORRY!!! You're on THE LIST!!" message?
hahahah no way! this is hilarious!
I'd prefer "No Raid for You!"
Someone suggested once, of during a raid being able to 'tag' a merc. Then once the raid is through being able to report that merc if they did not hit. This was so they could clearly see that these were low hitting mercs and not just mercs coming in last minute. Doing this would also generate a report for the devs to look at. Maybe even where they can make it they don't have to look at it unless they get a ping that toons on an account has been doing this so much in so much time.
Personally I would be happy with at least some sort of reporting system. Even better one that tells the merc they are or will be reported.
For example, I had a merc join Lockbolt in phase 2, hit 3 times. There was a good 15 minutes before the raid ended so even if he came to the raid with only 6 energy. He had plenty of time for regen to hit 2 or 3 more times. And I know he was not called away to rl. Because he was in global chatting away up to 2-5 minutes after raid was done. Plus he had also posted in global, after his three hits, #done raiding.
So it would have been nice to have a way to tag them, and they get a mail, pop up, or whisper to inform him he had been tagged and would be reported for bad raiding at end of raid if he did not make an attempt to raid. And that some action would be taken if he has made a habit of low hitting raids he mercs.
Bbbb wrote:Jumper wrote:DreamingDæmon wrote: pressing Join and getting a "SORRY!!! You're on THE LIST!!" message?
hahahah no way! this is hilarious!
I'd prefer "No Raid for You!"
I vote for "All your sandbagging are belong to us"
Bbbb wrote:Jumper wrote:DreamingDæmon wrote: pressing Join and getting a "SORRY!!! You're on THE LIST!!" message?
hahahah no way! this is hilarious!
I'd prefer "No Raid for You!"
An audio clip of HAL9000?
"I'm sorry skunk, I'm afraid you can't do that."
DreamingDæmon wrote:Lots of good ideas here.
I'm not sure about applying timescales to the blacklist, it seems unnecessarily complicated and adds an extra level of administration, both on the database and for the guild. The individuals involved have been acting like this for a long time in most cases, and have had plenty of time to understand that their behaviour is not appreciated - yet they continue. If they want to turn over a new leaf and play nicely, fine, but let them contact the guilds that have said "no" and ask to be removed from the list, rather than effectively just giving them a time-out. This keeps the membership control with the guild, which is the point of all this, AND keeps implementation as simple as possible.
I think the first idea that prevents an overzealous officer blacklisting a merc for no reason will get Venan's undivided attention. We could end up with whole guilds being blacklisted from others' raids - extreme example, but what would prevent it? Concerns like that could well be preventing Venan from making a genuine decision (aside from 'do nothing'), as well as the problem that a tiny minority of players is causing the issue.