Book of Heroes

Blacklist Deadbeat Mercs · page 5

Capricorn_Rainbucket

Mon Apr 6, 2015 3:59 pm
Maybe instead of making officers and gm kick people it's built into the game so that if you don't do x amount of rpp then game boots you from the raid. That way don't need black list or worry about people abusing power for stupid reasons. This prolly been mentioned before maybe but I think it would work ^^
Edit**** so I think having like a time limit when you join would be beneficial to go with the min you have to drop say I dunno 30 mins <~~~ that's plenty time

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Apr 6, 2015 4:04 pm
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:Maybe instead of making officers and gm kick people it's built into the game so that if you don't do x amount of rpp then game boots you from the raid. That way don't need black list or worry about people abusing power for stupid reasons. This prolly been mentioned before maybe but I think it would work ^^
Edit**** so I think having like a time limit when you join would be beneficial to go with the min you have to drop say I dunno 30 mins <~~~ that's plenty time

It has been mentioned before, but it's still a good idea.

Capricorn_Rainbucket

Mon Apr 6, 2015 4:15 pm
@ ily
Ty ^^ I think think it's a good idea too cause that way it's objective and can't be abused. Also you know people's feelings don't get hurt cause they are "banned" instead it's like if you get kicked it's on you, the player, not the guild.
Why does it matter if a guild blacklists an entire other guild. It's their prerogative and will only, likely, hurt them in the long run. If other people don't like it, that aren't blacklisted, they will steer clear from mercing for that guild.

On a seperate note, people need to learn to not let their feeling get hurt just because someone has decided they don't want them in their raids, for whatever reason.

With that said, I will be teaching a desensitivity class in PvP chat later tonight. Jumper will be assisting me ;-)
Ilyana wrote:
I think the first idea that prevents an overzealous officer blacklisting a merc for no reason will get Venan's undivided attention. We could end up with whole guilds being blacklisted from others' raids - extreme example, but what would prevent it? Concerns like that could well be preventing Venan from making a genuine decision (aside from 'do nothing'), as well as the problem that a tiny minority of players is causing the issue.

What is wrong with Balcklisting whole guilds? the point is each guild should have the right to let whomever they want in and block whomever they want out.
Saraa wrote:Why does it matter if a guild blacklists an entire other guild. It's their prerogative and will only, likely, hurt them in the long run. If other people don't like it, that aren't blacklisted, they will steer clear from mercing for that guild.

On a seperate note, people need to learn to not let their feeling get hurt just because someone has decided they don't want them in their raids, for whatever reason.

With that said, I will be teaching a desensitivity class in PvP chat later tonight. Jumper will be assisting me ;-)

hahaha yes what sara said. I "jumped" the gun on my last post (Ily loves that pun)

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Mon Apr 6, 2015 9:17 pm
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:Maybe instead of making officers and gm kick people it's built into the game so that if you don't do x amount of rpp then game boots you from the raid. That way don't need black list or worry about people abusing power for stupid reasons. This prolly been mentioned before maybe but I think it would work ^^
Edit**** so I think having like a time limit when you join would be beneficial to go with the min you have to drop say I dunno 30 mins <~~~ that's plenty time


If you repeatedly don't do enough rpp in a raid eventually the game not only boots U from the raid, it boots U from the game and opens up a one player game like candy crush.
I definitely agree this is an issue that needs to be addressed. In addition to the blacklist (or in lieu of it if the blacklist isn't feasible for whatever reason) I'd like for guilds to be able to impose optional requirements on who qualifies to merc in addition to the minimum requirements to raid.

Example Additional Requirements:
1. Minimum might and/or level. This could prevent mercs who are relatively weak and therefore might decide not to contribute in more difficult phases.
2. Current energy. This would prevent those mercs who join with no energy and only contribute whatever pittance they regen during the raid, assuming they even stick around. The requirement could be a percentage of the player's maximum energy instead of a number so people without maximum loyalty/sigils would not be penalized.
3. Not currently in another raid. This one is self explanatory, but should be accompanied by an option for the merc to leave the raid if the kills per minute needed to finish the raid reaches a preset number, which could be a different number depending on the raid.
4. Recent rpp in raids. This rating could be adjusted slightly based on the merc's starting energy and their total time in the raid, and averaged over a period of time like a week. Obviously this would be more difficult to implement than ideas 1-3, but it would be the most useful option to have.

Those are my main ideas, but a huge list of more minor options could be provided, like:
-Home guild raid contribution.
-% of merced raids the player comments in the host guild's chat.
-recent online time per day
-recent energy used per day
-join date
-has Venan account
-minimum OR maximum number of merced raids in the past day/week/whatever.

I think the extra merc filters would be an AWESOME feature that would help those players stymied by passwords (like me, since I never know who to ask for it and I'm way too shy to actually ask even if I did).

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Apr 7, 2015 6:48 am
Jumper wrote:
Saraa wrote:Why does it matter if a guild blacklists an entire other guild. It's their prerogative and will only, likely, hurt them in the long run. If other people don't like it, that aren't blacklisted, they will steer clear from mercing for that guild.

On a seperate note, people need to learn to not let their feeling get hurt just because someone has decided they don't want them in their raids, for whatever reason.

With that said, I will be teaching a desensitivity class in PvP chat later tonight. Jumper will be assisting me ;-)

hahaha yes what sara said. I "jumped" the gun on my last post (Ily loves that pun)

What can I say, I love puns. Especially Arnold Schwarzenegger ones.

I think it matters to Venan that such a feature is seen as fair and is not abused, but it was an extreme example and you're right that such silly blacklisting would just hurt the guild involved.
You have to appeal to venan's strong pride and sensibility in order to get this feature. Lets say we make it 10 gold shields to kick a merc out. Or maybe have a Guild perks type of thing. For only 100 gold shields guilds get the ability to kick mercs and other perks for the month. This keeps Venan's pockets filled and members happy then.