Book of Heroes

Blacklist Deadbeat Mercs · page 3

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Sun Apr 5, 2015 10:29 pm
Maybe the blacklist can be temporary? Maybe 3 months or so? Maybe Venan doens t want a permanent blacklist?
I was thinking back to where someone said something about a merc rating of a sort.

Maybe set a required merc rating when you set merc numbers to help lower the bad mercs in higher guilds

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 10:45 pm
Sàlád_ wrote:I was thinking back to where someone said something about a merc rating of a sort.

Maybe set a required merc rating when you set merc numbers to help lower the bad mercs in higher guilds

Banning bad mercs is a big part of this desired Blacklist. But included with that is keeping certain players out of your guild permanently. A rating system could come in down the line, but that involves more complex coding. The Blacklist is a simple change that can be implemented quickly and easily. Baby steps at least shows progress and forward thinking. Then we can build on it from there.

Venan, you don't have to bite off more than you can chew right now. You are busy thinking of all the ways this could go wrong so you code everything perfectly from the start. While I admire the desire to get it perfect from the start, in this case, we don't need fancy and perfect. We just need SOMETHING, and we need it asap.

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Sun Apr 5, 2015 11:02 pm
I agree they should try something. Even if it doesn't work out then Venan can say hey we tried it and it was a disaster
Some very good points have been raised in this thread.

When I started playing there wasn't any guild loyalty, in got introduced to stop player from joining a guild to do one raid with them before moving on to the next guild that is doing the raid they want.
Venan said at the time mercs wasn't an unexpected by product of how the game is set up and gave us guild loyalty.

Please recognize the need that we have to keep one hitters out of our raids and from joining our guilds, they take up room that someone else could use and who wants their guild to be associated with disrespectful players.

One final thing
You found a way to give the few that wanted it a skirt now find a way for us to manage our own raids.
DarioR wrote:You could also add an option for mercs acceptance

In addition to the free join and password join you could add the "request to join" a certain raid that has to be accepted, so that a guild can choose its mercs. Same as for joining a guild.

This would solve it all!!

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Mon Apr 6, 2015 12:56 am
Dhampie wrote:
DarioR wrote:You could also add an option for mercs acceptance

In addition to the free join and password join you could add the "request to join" a certain raid that has to be accepted, so that a guild can choose its mercs. Same as for joining a guild.

This would solve it all!!

This would add extra work, and a time delay for mercs trying to join a raid, if it had to be approved in the same manner we have to accept applicants trying to join a closed guild. The problem with that process is there is no in your face notification of someone trying to join. We have to continually check the door to see if anyone is waiting. If we could get some sort of real time notification someone would like to join, such as a little symbol in the corner of the screen somewhere, and all officers could see this, then I wouldn't mind this if this was the best venan could do. But this also requires a proactive approach, and all officers might not know who has been naughty and who has been nice. The Blacklist is something no one has to check regularly to know if someone should be accepted or not.

Jiggy_the_Unique_One

Mon Apr 6, 2015 3:31 am
Perhaps not make it permanent right away. Perhaps run it similar to silences when folks break rules. In this instance, they are penalized for doing it for a set period of time. Repeated offenses get longer sentences ultimately leading up to a perma if they continue doing it. At least in this case it gives guilds what they want and it gives those that one hit a chance to correct the error of there ways. Not the best solution but at least it is fair in that it doesn't too hastily come down on someone who isn't a repeat offender but does punish those that are in the long run that continue to hinder guild raids that they merc in. I don't know perhaps I'm too optimistic in thinking folks can change. Anyway just another suggestion.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Mon Apr 6, 2015 4:50 am
Jiggy_the_Unique_One wrote:Perhaps not make it permanent right away. Perhaps run it similar to silences when folks break rules. In this instance, they are penalized for doing it for a set period of time. Repeated offenses get longer sentences ultimately leading up to a perma if they continue doing it. At least in this case it gives guilds what they want and it gives those that one hit a chance to correct the error of there ways. Not the best solution but at least it is fair in that it doesn't too hastily come down on someone who isn't a repeat offender but does punish those that are in the long run that continue to hinder guild raids that they merc in. I don't know perhaps I'm too optimistic in thinking folks can change. Anyway just another suggestion.

You make a good point. Part of the goal here is to effect change in behavior. If people are held accountable for their mercing actions, maybe they will learn to become good mercs. And if they don't, then this will keep them from joining anyway.
I agree that allowing guilds to have a blacklist would:
1. Prevent guilds from having to close their doors and guildies having to apply and wait to get accepted back in.

2. Prevent guilds from having to password protect their raids.

3. Prevent regular low hitting mercs from joining their raids.

4. Prevent frustration and  disharmony in  guild chat about low hitting mercs.

So a big +1 for a blacklist from me :)