Book of Heroes

Blacklist Deadbeat Mercs · page 2

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 9:42 am
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:I like the deadbeat Mercs they make me look good by comparison >,<

LOL, so true! :lol:
I remember, back before guild loyalty, when to merc a raid, you had to temporarily join the guild. I also remember someone venting in global how he had been kicked from the guild moments from the raid's end so a regular member could get 2nd place. As a result, he received zero raid rewards. I don't remember the guild that did it, but I do remember not mercing for them because of that incident.

Why the story, you are probably wondering. Deadbeat mercs definitely can hurt a guild going for gold or just trying to finish a raid. At the same time, guilds can and have hurt legitimate mercs for purely selfish reasons. For that reason, I think Juggernaut's suggestion of a blacklist merits implementation. Passwords are cumbersome. To make them work, you would have to detail a member to be in global chat and a player to be in PvP chat to take requests for the password. Additionally, I have merced for non-English speaking guilds before. I would have difficulty figuring out which global to be in to ask for a password.

If Venan refuses to allow a blacklist because blacklists aren't nice or for whatever other reason, then they need to provide guilds a way to remove non-hitting players. Notice, I said non-hitting players. If they haven't hit in 15 minutes, it appears they aren't waiting for energy to regenerate. Or if they join in p1 and have 315 RPP or less and the raid is now in p3, then they could be removed. Removed mercs could still keep what they have earned to protect against selfish boots.

It would also be nice for Venan to provide a way for mercs to remove themselves from a raid. If I join a raid and realize I can't finish it, I should have a way to show myself the door and open that slot for someone who can hit. Likewise, if I join a raid and discover the guild has no plans of finishing it, I shouldn't be held hostage to that particular raid until time expires.
You could also add an option for mercs acceptance

In addition to the free join and password join you could add the "request to join" a certain raid that has to be accepted, so that a guild can choose its mercs. Same as for joining a guild.
Global chat is a perfect example of a place where huge amounts of abuse is possible. I understand that Venan feels a GM having a banhammer could potentially be abused.

My suggestion: impliment it and IF there is huge abuse...pull the code out and try something else. At least TRY IT and see how it goes. 30 days.
LBriggs, I'm against removing mercs from the current raid. I just want the ability to block them from joining future raids.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 10:14 pm
Bbbb wrote:LBriggs, I'm against removing mercs from the current raid. I just want the ability to block them from joining future raids.

While my frustration in the moment makes me wanna boot these people from raids, the level headed thinking side of me says the Blacklist is the best way to deal with this situation without opening the door for abuse, like we used to deal with long ago.

We still have the ability to boot abusive players from our guild. If we can add the Blacklist, this will keep them from coming back. I say this is an acceptable measure to manage our guild.

No, this won't help a guild in the heat of battle, trying to use those valuable few spaces to try and save a raid. But it is a huge step towards alleviating one of the biggest complaints in the game right now.

There are a ton of ways we could make this implementation highly technical, as many of the suggestions made before will exhibit, such as rpp thresholds, time limits, entrance approval, etc. And those are great suggestions to consider for down the road. But for right now, the quick and easy fix is the very simple Blacklist idea. If you want to enter a raid, or join a guild, the system does an instantaneous check to see if you meet the might requirement. Now we add a new check to see if your name is on the Blacklist before granting access. If possible, venan handles device ID matching behind the scenes, in case people change their account name. But if not, most won't bother changing their name just to get around a name ban. If they do, we report them for further blatantly abusing the system, and venan can consider a full game ban if we warranted.

The whole point is something is better than nothing. People will learn, play fair or you won't be able to play at all. If we hold people responsible for their actions, that will solve the vast majority of the problems.