Book of Heroes

Blacklist Deadbeat Mercs

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 7:07 am
***This is being reposted without the details venan has said are against the terms of the forum. It is also being posted with hopes the forum mod, BJ will leave it alone, and especially not change the title like he so frequently does. BJ, please remember, you are a MOD, not a censor of non violating posts or posts that don't meet your preferred "suggestion stub" terminology***

When will you allow us to ban mercs from joining our raids, or allow us to boot deadbeat mercs who don't hit? Everyone knows how much (CENSORED) sucks as a merc. He is famous in the game for pissing off every guild he mercs at. Lately, a new player, (CENSORED) from (CENSORED) has been doing something similar. He joins a raid with 3 alts and then sits at the bottom of the raid until maybe he finds time to hit. He regularly stays at 100rpp during a large chunk of the raid, and often ends raids still at 100rpp. He has never responded when we try to talk to him in chat so probably doesn't even understand English. Hard to tell him we don't like his selfishness when he can't understand us.

Putting a password on a raid, or on a guild is something not many guilds like to do. (CENSORED) has lost lots of members because they kept a password on their guild and people don't have time to wait to be accepted when they want to do a quick dump and run. If we password protect raids, no one will join either cause they have no clue who to whisper for the password.

We need a way to manage our guild and raids without impeding the majority of players who play with common decency. You already have a methodology for ignoring players. We want a way for our guild to blacklist players so they can not join our guild or merc our raids. And we would also love a way to boot mercs who don't hit after joining a raid so we can accept a new merc in that space. I don't care if we lose benefit of their kills and we must kill a few more waves after booting them. The will only be booted for not killing to begin with, so this won't be a problem for us. If you want to protect players from unfairly being booted, make a setting so they can't be booted from the raid after they get 10 kills or something like that. At the same time, if they are being rude or abusive in chat, we need a way to boot them from our chat as well, even if they get to keep their rpp and raid rewards.

Bottom line is we need a way to manage our guild and ever since you took away our banhammer, we have been left defenseless against people who don't deserve to be in our guild.

Please let us know how you plan to address this issue that has been a problem for a long time, and has support from many players and guilds in the game.

Thank you.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 7:31 am
This was venan's reply to my email to customer service with the same text as above:


We have not yet decided on the best way to address this issue. There is a lot of negative aspects to allow players to kick other players out of a raid. For the time being, you need to password protect your raids if you do not want certain players to appear in there. We will attempt to find the best solution to help address this issue while also not allowing players to abuse the requested feature.

Please let me know if you need any other assistance.



Michael aka "CheMClarc"
Customer Support Team
Venan Entertainment, Inc.


OK venan, we understand you haven't settled on the best way to REMOVE deadbeat mercs from a raid, despite the many great suggestions posted in these forums over the past couple years. Sounds to me like you are just dragging your feet on the issue that has been around for a very long time. However, the whole point of my post, and my email to you, was not just about booting mercs. It was about PREVENTING them from joining our raid, or guild, in the first place. If they can't get in, we don't have to boot them.

Now, your boiler plate response in the email above was laughable in that it completely ignored a major point of my comments to you. I clearly pointed out that the use of passwords is grossly undesired among the majority of guilds and for the majority of raids opened to mercs. Yes, I understand there are circumstances where password do are desired. I'm not addressing those situations. I am telling you that many of us DO NOT WANT TO USE PASSWORDS to manage our guilds and raids. We don't want to restrict the many many wonderful players in this game, just to keep the few terrible people from ruining the experience for everyone else.

It cannot possibly be that hard to give a guild the ability to ban certain players from joining its guild or raids. Why do you feel it is better to keep out everyone by using passwords, instead of keeping out only a select very few people who have abused the privilege of raiding with a particular guild?

To date, I still have not seen a response from venan on the BLACKLIST idea. Instead, we keep having posts locked and removed entirely from view. I understand this is your game and you can do with it whatever you want. But you clearly want to keep your paying players happy. You clearly want our suggestions on ways to make this game better. Please share with us how you feel a PASSIVE BLACKLIST is a bad idea, while you supposedly continue to consider a way to give back our BANHAMMER without hurting people's feelings. While I very much desire to have our BANHAMMER back, I will very happily settle for a blacklist instead if I can only have one or the other.

Venan, I eagerly await your official response on a time frame for implementing this highly desired Blacklist which has the support of many players of this game.

Thank you.

Wølfÿ_Thè_Lïttlè_Føx

Sun Apr 5, 2015 7:57 am
They won't do it. Simple as that, if they haven't already, they won't. They will keep locking it untill it finally stops all together. Just use a password and give it to people you and your guild trusts.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 8:07 am
Wolfy_Loves_Freddy wrote:They won't do it. Simple as that, if they haven't already, they won't. They will keep locking it untill it finally stops all together. Just use a password and give it to people you and your guild trusts.

We aren't trying to be elitist and let in only people we trust. We are trying to be accepting of everyone who wants to play fair and not abuse the privilege of joining a raid they can't otherwise access. Why should everyone be excluded from joining a raid they want just because they don't know who to ask for a password, or don't have time to ask around and wait when they simply want to dump their energy during a few free minutes of time.

A blacklist is the easiest solution that impedes very few people, and is the most lenient solution to allow the many people free and easy access to raids they wanna join.
+1000000

Most mercs are GREAT contributors, after that gold just as much as the guild whose raid they've joined.

Passwords just keep them out, as well as the undesirables.

Guild masters/officers NEED great huge whomping banhammers. There are really only a handful of lazy deadbeat leeching pond scum waste of flesh butt pirates out there, a blacklist wouldn't be a HUGE thing to maintain.
+ plus one from me, there should be an option to block these players, we had one in our last PM that bought 3 toons in & only hit twice on each, I think he was trying to sabotage the raid, which is very bad form.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 8:43 am
Yet, it seems like Venan is deadset on protecting the interests of the very few deadbeat mercs, over providing a way to keep the 99.9% of quality players happy.

I don't see any posts by those deadbeat mercs begging venan to not allow guilds to blacklist them. Yet venan is taking their side on this issue by not acting on the uproar that has been ongoing for quite some time now. Whose interests are you trying to protect venan??? What are you afraid is going to happen anyway? Do you think tons of players will be blacklisted so they can't raid anywhere anymore? The only people who will be blacklisted are the ones who disrespect the guilds they join. If players act in good faith, and give a good effort, no one is going to ban them. As far as I'm concerned, I won't support banning anyone just because they have a bad showing or two in a raid. We all get that real life happens sometimes. What we will be watching for is the types of things we are already noticing, the same merc doing the same shady stuff over and over and over and over and over again. We will blacklist mercs for a pattern of abuse, not for a single instance of losing connection, or having their boss walk in on them when they are raiding while working. And all of us will gladly give a pass to the guy whose wife walks in and gives them the option of "this or that".

We aren't asking for a fourth class, 30 new levels, justicars to not suck during onslaught, or a better pvp system that isn't reliant on RNG. (Yet) We are simply asking for a little easy coding to allow us to manage our guilds and raids in a way that is fair for everyone who deserves that fairness.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 8:46 am
Schoey wrote:+ plus one from me, there should be an option to block these players, we had one in our last PM that bought 3 toons in & only hit twice on each, I think he was trying to sabotage the raid, which is very bad form.

Actually, he only hit twice on one toon. The other toons, he hit once each. Total of 4 hits over 3 toons. He was one of the first 10 of 35 mercs to join the PM raid, and joined during P1. And this is not a case of oops, I got busy with life all of a sudden. This is the latest repeat offender who is the inspiration for all this rhetoric lately.
/signed

Something needs to be done... Long time ago there was talk about retooling raids for this reason, time to do it!